Human Care Research Team, Tokyo Metropolitan Institute for Geriatrics and Gerontology, Tokyo, Japan.
Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Macquarie University, NSW, Australia.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Jul 11;26:e57842. doi: 10.2196/57842.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, much misinformation and disinformation emerged and spread rapidly via the internet, posing a severe public health challenge. While the need for eHealth literacy (eHL) has been emphasized, few studies have compared the difficulties involved in seeking and using COVID-19 information between adult internet users with low or high eHL.
This study examines the association between eHL and web-based health information-seeking behaviors among adult Japanese internet users. Moreover, this study qualitatively shed light on the difficulties encountered in seeking and using this information and examined its relationship with eHL.
This cross-sectional internet-based survey (October 2021) collected data from 6000 adult internet users who were equally divided into sample groups by gender, age, and income. We used the Japanese version of the eHL Scale (eHEALS). We also used a Digital Health Literacy Instrument (DHLI) adapted to the COVID-19 pandemic to assess eHL after we translated it to Japanese. Web-based health information-seeking behaviors were assessed by using a 10-item list of web sources and evaluating 10 topics participants searched for regarding COVID-19. Sociodemographic and other factors (eg, health-related behavior) were selected as covariates. Furthermore, we qualitatively explored the difficulties in information seeking and using. The descriptive contents of the responses regarding difficulties in seeking and using COVID-19 information were analyzed using an inductive qualitative content analysis approach.
Participants with high eHEALS and DHLI scores on information searching, adding self-generated information, evaluating reliability, determining relevance, and operational skills were more likely to use all web sources of information about COVID-19 than those with low scores. However, there were negative associations between navigation skills and privacy protection scores when using several information sources, such as YouTube (Google LLC), to search for COVID-19 information. While half of the participants reported no difficulty seeking and using COVID-19 information, participants who reported any difficulties, including information discernment, incomprehensible information, information overload, and disinformation, had lower DHLI score. Participants expressed significant concerns regarding "information quality and credibility," "abundance and shortage of relevant information," "public trust and skepticism," and "credibility of COVID-19-related information." Additionally, they disclosed more specific concerns, including "privacy and security concerns," "information retrieval challenges," "anxieties and panic," and "movement restriction."
Although Japanese internet users with higher eHEALS and total DHLI scores were more actively using various web sources for COVID-19 information, those with high navigation skills and privacy protection used web-based information about COVID-19 cautiously compared with those with lower proficiency. The study also highlighted an increased need for information discernment when using social networking sites in the "Health 2.0" era. The identified categories and themes from the qualitative content analysis, such as "information quality and credibility," suggest a framework for addressing the myriad challenges anticipated in future infodemics.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,大量错误和虚假信息通过互联网迅速传播,对公共卫生构成严重挑战。尽管人们强调需要电子健康素养(eHL),但很少有研究比较高低 eHL 的成年互联网用户在搜索和使用 COVID-19 信息方面的困难。
本研究旨在检验 eHL 与日本成年互联网用户基于网络的健康信息搜索行为之间的关联。此外,本研究还从质的角度探讨了搜索和使用这些信息所遇到的困难,并探讨了其与 eHL 的关系。
这是一项基于互联网的横断面调查(2021 年 10 月),共纳入 6000 名成年互联网用户,他们按照性别、年龄和收入均等分为样本组。我们使用了日本版电子健康素养量表(eHEALS)。我们还使用了针对 COVID-19 进行了改编的数字健康素养工具(DHLI)来评估 eHL。基于网络的健康信息搜索行为通过使用包含 10 个网络来源的清单和评估参与者搜索的 10 个 COVID-19 相关主题来评估。选择社会人口统计学和其他因素(例如健康相关行为)作为协变量。此外,我们还从质的角度探讨了信息搜索和使用的困难。使用归纳定性内容分析方法分析了关于 COVID-19 信息搜索和使用困难的回复的描述性内容。
在信息搜索、添加自生成信息、评估可靠性、确定相关性和操作技能方面,eHEALS 和 DHLI 评分较高的参与者比评分较低的参与者更有可能使用所有与 COVID-19 相关的网络信息来源。然而,在使用某些信息来源(如 YouTube(Google LLC))搜索 COVID-19 信息时,导航技能和隐私保护评分之间存在负相关。尽管有一半的参与者表示在搜索和使用 COVID-19 信息方面没有困难,但报告存在任何困难的参与者,包括信息辨别、信息难以理解、信息过载和虚假信息,DHLI 评分较低。参与者对“信息质量和可信度”、“相关信息的丰富程度和短缺程度”、“公众信任和怀疑”以及“与 COVID-19 相关信息的可信度”表示了极大的关注。此外,他们还透露了更具体的担忧,包括“隐私和安全问题”、“信息检索挑战”、“焦虑和恐慌”以及“行动限制”。
尽管 eHEALS 和总 DHLI 评分较高的日本互联网用户更积极地使用各种网络来源获取 COVID-19 信息,但与技能较低的用户相比,具有较高导航技能和隐私保护技能的用户在使用基于网络的 COVID-19 信息时更为谨慎。研究还强调了在“健康 2.0”时代使用社交网络时需要提高信息辨别能力。定性内容分析中确定的类别和主题,如“信息质量和可信度”,为解决未来信息泛滥中预期的诸多挑战提供了框架。