Centro Universitario Regional del Este, Universidad de la República, Rocha, Uruguay.
Departamento de Sistemas Ambientales, Facultad de Agronomía, Universidad de la República, Montevideo, Uruguay.
Environ Manage. 2024 Sep;74(3):609-622. doi: 10.1007/s00267-024-02019-8. Epub 2024 Jul 21.
The illegal wildlife trade (IWT) is a global phenomenon that adversely affects biodiversity and human well-being. Understanding how institutions manage this trade is crucial for reducing its negative impacts. Latin America has the fewest IWT studies globally; thus, science in support of more effective institutional management of IWT is limited. This study aims to bridge the researcher-practitioner gap by providing applicable results and involving control institutions. To this end, we examine the strengths and weaknesses of Uruguay's institutions in addressing this issue, introducing the concept of institutional management competence to the knowledge base about IWT. Based on this case study, we aimed to generate inputs to guide policymakers in achieving better control of the IWT, contributing to reduce the researcher-practitioner gap. From an interdisciplinary perspective that articulates qualitative and quantitative methods, the study presents the following results: (a) Uruguay's network for addressing illegal wildlife trade involves numerous institutions whose articulation has a high degree of informality; (b) these institutions address different stages of trafficking based on their roles, jurisdiction, and engagement; (c) main weaknesses include insufficient state-level prioritisation, weak institutional coordination, inadequate training, insufficient infrastructure, space and personnel to handle the volume of seized animals, lack of proper facilities for seized animals, and a need for better-organised information. Our results help shed light on the IWT management structures in Uruguay and identifies where direct improvements can be made to strengthen the institutional responses to global IWT.
非法野生动植物贸易(IWT)是一种全球性现象,它对生物多样性和人类福祉产生负面影响。了解机构如何管理这种贸易对于减少其负面影响至关重要。拉丁美洲在全球范围内进行的 IWT 研究最少;因此,支持更有效地管理 IWT 的科学研究有限。本研究旨在通过提供适用的结果并涉及控制机构来弥合研究人员与实践者之间的差距。为此,我们考察了乌拉圭机构在解决这一问题方面的优势和劣势,将机构管理能力的概念引入到关于 IWT 的知识基础中。基于这项案例研究,我们旨在为政策制定者提供指导,以实现更好地控制 IWT,有助于缩小研究人员与实践者之间的差距。本研究从一个将定性和定量方法结合起来的跨学科视角出发,提出了以下结果:(a)乌拉圭处理非法野生动植物贸易的网络涉及众多机构,其协调具有高度的非正式性;(b)这些机构根据其角色、管辖权和参与程度,针对不同的走私阶段开展工作;(c)主要的弱点包括国家层面的优先排序不足、机构协调不力、培训不足、基础设施不足、人员和空间来处理缴获的动物数量、缺乏适当的设施来处理缴获的动物,以及需要更好组织的信息。我们的研究结果有助于了解乌拉圭的 IWT 管理结构,并确定在哪些方面可以直接进行改进,以加强对全球 IWT 的机构应对。