Schydlo Franziska, Sterz Jasmina, Stefanescu Maria-Christina, Kadmon Martina, König Sarah, Rüsseler Miriam, Walcher Felix, Adili Farzin
Department of Anaesthesiology and Surgical Intensive Care, Klinikum Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany.
Department of Trauma, Hand and Reconstructive Surgery, Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Innov Surg Sci. 2024 Jun 21;9(2):99-108. doi: 10.1515/iss-2023-0073. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Due to increasing workload and rising expectations for both undergraduate and speciality training in medicine, teaching in a clinical environment can be challenging. The "Train the Trainer" course, developed by CAL (Chirurgische Arbeitsgemeinschaft Lehre, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Chirurgie (DGCH)), aims to assist clinical teachers in their task. This study investigates the effect the course has on participants' self-efficacy and teaching motivation.
Prior to attending the course, participants anonymously completed a 50-question pre-course questionnaire using standardised questions to gather information on biographical data teaching experience, and validated tools measuring teaching motivation and self-efficacy (PRE). Directly after completing the course, participants evaluated it using a 25-question post-course questionnaire (POST1). At least 12 months after the course, participants received a follow-up questionnaire (POST2) by mail. This 44-question form aimed to gather biographical data, review the teaching methods participants had used since their training, and reassess their teaching motivation and self-efficacy.
Between June 2016 and October 2019, 20 TTT courses were held across six German medical faculties. Data were gathered from 241 participants. After the course, 182 POST2 questionnaires were mailed, 61 of which were returned (equals a 39 % return rate). The findings revealed significant increases in teacher self-efficacy (p=0.0025), identified regulation (p=0.0000), and career motivation (p=0.0044). In contrast, there was a significant decrease in introjected regulation (p=0.0048). When comparing the participants to a reference sample selected from literature, significant differences emerged in intrinsic motivation (p=0.0000) and amotivation (p=0.0025).
Course participants already showed strong intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy before taking the course. After completing it, their confidence to meet specific teaching demands based on their abilities had increased. Notably, changes in motivational dimensions identified and introjected regulation point towards a shift in motivational sources, indicating a more self-regulated approach towards participants' teaching activities. Further research is needed to determine how much of this change was due to course participation.
由于医学本科和专科培训的工作量不断增加,对培训的期望也日益提高,临床环境中的教学可能具有挑战性。由德国外科协会(DGCH)下属的Chirurgische Arbeitsgemeinschaft Lehre(CAL)开发的“培训培训师”课程旨在协助临床教师完成教学任务。本研究调查了该课程对参与者自我效能感和教学动机的影响。
在参加课程之前,参与者使用标准化问题匿名完成一份包含50个问题的课前问卷,以收集有关个人资料、教学经验以及测量教学动机和自我效能感的经过验证的工具的信息(PRE)。在完成课程后,参与者立即使用一份包含25个问题的课后问卷对课程进行评估(POST1)。在课程结束至少12个月后,参与者通过邮件收到一份随访问卷(POST2)。这份包含44个问题的问卷旨在收集个人资料,回顾参与者自培训以来使用的教学方法,并重新评估他们的教学动机和自我效能感。
在2016年6月至2019年10月期间,德国六个医学院校共举办了20期培训培训师课程。收集了241名参与者的数据。课程结束后,邮寄了182份POST2问卷,其中61份被退回(回复率为39%)。研究结果显示,教师的自我效能感(p = 0.0025)、认同调节(p = 0.0000)和职业动机(p = 0.0044)显著提高。相比之下,内摄调节显著下降(p = 0.0048)。当将参与者与从文献中选取的参考样本进行比较时,内在动机(p = 0.0000)和无动机(p = 0.0025)出现了显著差异。
课程参与者在参加课程之前就已经表现出强烈的内在动机和自我效能感。课程结束后,他们基于自身能力满足特定教学要求的信心有所增强。值得注意的是,认同调节和内摄调节这两个动机维度的变化表明动机来源发生了转变,这意味着参与者对教学活动采取了更加自我调节的方式。需要进一步研究以确定这种变化在多大程度上归因于课程参与。