Mont'Alverne Camila, Arguedas Amy Ross, Banerjee Sayan, Toff Benjamin, Fletcher Richard, Nielsen Rasmus Kleis
Lecturer in Journalism, Media, and Communication, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK.
Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Public Opin Q. 2024 Jul 22;88(SI):681-707. doi: 10.1093/poq/nfae019. eCollection 2024.
Electoral misinformation, where citizens believe false or misleading claims about the electoral process and electoral institutions-sometimes actively and strategically spread by political actors-is a challenge to public confidence in elections specifically and democracy more broadly. In this article, we analyze a combination of 42 million clicks in links and apps from behavioral tracking data of 2,200 internet users and a four-wave panel survey to investigate how different kinds of online news and media use relate to beliefs in electoral misinformation during a contentious political period-the 2022 Brazilian presidential elections. We find that, controlling for other factors, using news from legacy news media is associated with belief in fewer claims of electoral misinformation over time. We find null or inconsistent effects for using digital-born news media and various digital platforms, including Facebook and WhatsApp. Furthermore, we find that trust in news plays a significant role as a moderator. Belief in electoral misinformation, in turn, undermines trust in news. Overall, our findings document the important role of the news media as an institution in curbing electoral misinformation, even as they also underline the precarity of trust in news during contentious political periods.
选举错误信息,即公民相信有关选举过程和选举机构的虚假或误导性说法(有时由政治行为体积极且有策略地传播),不仅对公众对选举的信心构成挑战,更广泛地说,也对民主构成挑战。在本文中,我们结合了来自2200名互联网用户行为追踪数据中的4200万个链接和应用点击量,以及一项四波面板调查,以研究在一个充满争议的政治时期——2022年巴西总统选举期间,不同类型的在线新闻和媒体使用方式与选举错误信息信念之间的关系。我们发现,在控制其他因素的情况下,随着时间的推移,使用传统新闻媒体的新闻与对选举错误信息较少主张的信念相关。我们发现,使用数字原生新闻媒体和包括脸书和WhatsApp在内的各种数字平台的影响为零或不一致。此外,我们发现对新闻的信任作为一个调节变量起着重要作用。反过来,对选举错误信息的信念会削弱对新闻的信任。总体而言,我们的研究结果证明了新闻媒体作为一种机构在遏制选举错误信息方面的重要作用,尽管它们也强调了在充满争议的政治时期对新闻信任的不稳定。