Altay Sacha, Hoes Emma, Wojcieszak Magdalena
Political Science Department, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Communication, University of California, Davis, Davis, CA, USA.
Nat Hum Behav. 2025 Jun 27. doi: 10.1038/s41562-025-02205-6.
Many worry that news on social media leaves people uninformed or even misinformed. Here we conducted a preregistered two-wave online field experiment in France and Germany (N = 3,395) to estimate the effect of following the news on Instagram and WhatsApp. Participants were asked to follow two accounts for 2 weeks and activate the notifications. In the treatment condition, the accounts were those of news organizations, while in the control condition they covered cooking, cinema or art. The treatment enhanced current affairs knowledge, participants' ability to discern true from false news stories and awareness of true news stories, as well as trust in the news. The treatment had no significant effects on feelings of being informed, political efficacy, affective polarization and interest in news or politics. These results suggest that, while some forms of social media use are harmful, others are beneficial and can be leveraged to foster a well-informed society.
许多人担心社交媒体上的新闻会让人们了解不足甚至得到错误信息。在此,我们在法国和德国进行了一项预先注册的两阶段在线实地实验(N = 3395),以评估在照片墙(Instagram)和瓦次普(WhatsApp)上关注新闻的影响。参与者被要求关注两个账号,为期两周并开启通知功能。在处理条件下,这些账号是新闻机构的,而在对照条件下,它们涵盖烹饪、电影或艺术。该处理增强了时事知识、参与者辨别真假新闻报道的能力以及对真实新闻报道的认知,还有对新闻的信任。该处理对了解情况的感觉、政治效能感、情感两极分化以及对新闻或政治的兴趣没有显著影响。这些结果表明,虽然某些形式的社交媒体使用是有害的,但其他形式是有益的,并且可以被利用来培育一个消息灵通的社会。