Maisner Rose S, Kapadia Kailash, Berlin Ryan, Lee Edward S
Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Surgery, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Newark, New Jersey, USA.
Transgend Health. 2024 Jun 17;9(3):254-263. doi: 10.1089/trgh.2021.0215. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Given rising demand for gender affirmation surgery (GAS), lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and others' (LGBTQ+) patient care, and sexual and gender minority (SGM) representation in plastic surgery, we sought to analyze integrated residency programs' posts for LGBTQ+ content.
Programs were identified from the American Council of Academic Plastic Surgeons website. Accounts were searched for on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter. Posts uploaded through June 24, 2021 were analyzed. Mann-Whitney - and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used to compare content between programs.
Of 82 programs, 76 (92.7%), 31 (37.8%), and 30 (36.6%) have Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter accounts, respectively. Two hundred eighty-one (1.3%) posts displayed LGBTQ+ content, including educational (29.9%), research (17.4%), news (11.0%), resident interests (10.7%), pride/diversity (9.6%), posts to attract applicants/patients (7.5%), operative/clinic cases (6.8%), faculty spotlights (6.4%), and patient testimonials (1.1%). One hundred eighty-one (64.4%) posts described GAS overall, 42 (23.2%) described top, 32 (17.7%) described genital, and 32 (17.7%) described facial surgery. Instagram and Facebook have more LGBTQ+ content than Twitter (≤0.037). Newly accredited programs have significantly more LGBTQ+ content on Facebook (=0.036). Programs in the West, having more perceived prestige, or GAS fellowships tended to have more LGBTQ+ content.
Despite growing demand for GAS and thus training, 1% of content on plastic surgery residency social media accounts is LGBTQ+ related. Reasons for lack of representation require further investigation but may include (1) limited GAS and LGBTQ+ patient exposure during training or (2) lack of SGM inclusivity for residents, faculty, and patients.
鉴于性别肯定手术(GAS)的需求不断上升、女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋、跨性别者、酷儿及其他群体(LGBTQ+)的患者护理,以及整形手术中性少数群体(SGM)的代表性,我们试图分析综合住院医师培训项目中有关LGBTQ+内容的帖子。
从美国学术整形外科医师委员会网站确定项目。在照片墙(Instagram)、脸书(Facebook)和推特(Twitter)上搜索账号。分析截至2021年6月24日上传的帖子。采用曼-惠特尼检验和克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯检验比较各项目之间的内容。
在82个项目中,分别有76个(92.7%)、31个(37.8%)和30个(36.6%)拥有照片墙、脸书和推特账号。281条(1.3%)帖子展示了LGBTQ+内容,包括教育类(29.9%)、研究类(17.4%)、新闻类(11.0%)、住院医师兴趣类(10.7%)、骄傲/多样性类(9.6%)、吸引申请者/患者的帖子(7.5%)、手术/临床病例类(6.8%)、教员特写类(6.4%)和患者推荐类(1.1%)。181条(64.4%)帖子总体上描述了性别肯定手术,42条(23.2%)描述了胸部手术,32条(17.7%)描述了生殖器手术,32条(17.7%)描述了面部手术。照片墙和脸书上的LGBTQ+内容比推特上更多(≤0.037)。新获得认证的项目在脸书上有显著更多的LGBTQ+内容(P=0.036)。西部的项目、知名度更高的项目或有性别肯定手术奖学金的项目往往有更多的LGBTQ+内容。
尽管对性别肯定手术以及相关培训的需求不断增加,但整形手术住院医师社交媒体账号上1%的内容与LGBTQ+相关。缺乏代表性的原因需要进一步调查,但可能包括:(1)培训期间接触性别肯定手术和LGBTQ+患者的机会有限;或(2)住院医师、教员和患者缺乏对性少数群体的包容性。