Drumm Caitlin M, Martin Paolo C, Schulz Elizabeth V, Wyatt Tasha R
Department of Pediatrics, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, Maryland, USA.
Center for Health Professions Education, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, Maryland, USA.
Teach Learn Med. 2025 Aug-Sep;37(4):457-467. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2024.2386986. Epub 2024 Aug 8.
Patriarchal norms continue to disadvantage women in Graduate Medical Education (GME). These norms are made salient when women trainees are pregnant. Although it is known that pregnant trainees experience myriad challenges, their experiences have not been examined through the lens of gendered organizations. To understand why these challenges persist, this study critically examined the experiences of pregnant trainees and their program directors (PDs) with navigating pregnancy. From October 2022 to April 2023, we recruited 13 resident or fellow trainees who experienced pregnancy while in training and their corresponding PDs. Data, in the form of semi-structured interviews, were collected, transcribed, and analyzed using thematic analysis. Guiding the analysis was feminist theory, in particular Acker's conceptualization of the ideal worker. The ideal worker norm promotes a culture of individuals who are singularly dedicated to their work with no external distractions or demands upon their time or effort. Both sets of participants struggled with medicine's image of the ideal worker (i.e., a selfless and untethered professional). Trainees experienced guilt for using entitlements meant to assist them during this time, concern that their requests for help would signal personal weakness, and pressure to sacrifice their own wellbeing for work. While most PDs were aware of these phenomena, they experienced varying degrees of success in combating the negative effects of the ideal worker norm. In each case, the image of the ideal worker lurked in the background of medical training, shaping trainees' experiences and PDs' perceptions and guidance. This study shows that even though the number of women has increased in medicine, the profession's underlying culture continues to signal that they must live up to the profession's expectations of the ideal worker.
父权制规范在研究生医学教育(GME)中继续使女性处于不利地位。当女性学员怀孕时,这些规范就变得尤为突出。尽管已知怀孕的学员会经历无数挑战,但她们的经历尚未从性别化组织的角度进行审视。为了理解这些挑战为何持续存在,本研究批判性地考察了怀孕学员及其项目主任(PD)应对怀孕的经历。从2022年10月到2023年4月,我们招募了13名在培训期间怀孕的住院医师或研究员学员以及他们相应的项目主任。以半结构化访谈的形式收集数据,进行转录,并使用主题分析进行分析。指导分析的是女权主义理论,特别是阿克对理想员工的概念化。理想员工规范促进了一种文化,即个人全身心投入工作,没有外部干扰或对其时间和精力的要求。两组参与者都在与医学中理想员工的形象(即无私且不受束缚的专业人员)作斗争。学员们因在此期间使用旨在帮助他们的福利而感到内疚,担心他们寻求帮助的请求会表明个人软弱,并面临为工作牺牲自身福祉的压力。虽然大多数项目主任都意识到了这些现象,但他们在对抗理想员工规范的负面影响方面取得了不同程度的成功。在每种情况下,理想员工的形象都潜藏在医学培训的背景中,塑造着学员的经历以及项目主任的认知和指导。这项研究表明,尽管医学领域的女性数量有所增加,但该职业的潜在文化仍然表明,她们必须达到该职业对理想员工的期望。