Co-flowering richness has variable effects on pollen quantity and quality limitation in four Clarkia species.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Pollination failure occurs from insufficient pollen quantity or quality. However, the relative contributions of pollen quantity vs. quality to overall pollen limitation, and how this is affected by the co-flowering context, remain unknown for most plant populations. Here, we studied patterns of pollen deposition and pollen tube formation across populations of four predominately outcrossing species in the genus Clarkia to evaluate how the richness of co-flowering congeners affects the contribution of pollen quantity and quality to pollen limitation.

METHODS

We partition variation in pollen deposition and pollen tube production across individuals, populations and species to identify the main sources of variation in components of reproductive success. We further quantify the relative contribution of pollen quantity and quality limitation to the reproductive success of the four Clarkia species using piecewise regression analyses. Finally, we evaluate how variation in the number of co-flowering Clarkia species in the community affects the strength of pollen quality and quality limitation.

RESULTS

Across all contexts, pollen deposition and the proportion of pollen tubes produced varied greatly among individuals, populations and species, and these were not always correlated. For instance, C. xantiana received the smallest pollen loads yet produced the highest proportion of pollen tubes, while C. speciosa exhibited the opposite pattern. Yet, co-flowering richness had variable effects on the strength of pollen quantity and quality limitation among populations. Specifically, breakpoint values, which are an indicator of overall pollen limitation, were two-fold higher in the four-species community compared with one- and two-species communities for two Clarkia species, suggesting that pollen limitation can increase with increasing richness of co-flowering congeners.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results reveal a complex interplay between the quantity and quality of pollen limitation and co-flowering context that may have different evolutionary outcomes across species and populations.