Favaretto M, Rost M
Institute for Biomedical Ethics, University of Basel, Bernoullistrasse 28, 4056, Basel, Switzerland.
J Bioeth Inq. 2024 Aug 19. doi: 10.1007/s11673-024-10360-0.
Prenatal ultrasound is a non-invasive diagnostic examination. Despite the recognized diagnostic value, this technology raises complex ethical questions. The aim of this study is to provide a comprehensive analysis that coherently maps the ethical challenges raised by prenatal ultrasound examination, both 2D and 3D. We performed a systematic literature review. Six databases were systematically searched. The results highlight how concerns related to beneficence, informed consent, and autonomy are mainly related to routine use of prenatal ultrasound in the clinical context, while considerations linked to overmedicalization of pregnancy, discrimination, and fetal ontology were often reported in relation to the impact ultrasound is having on medicine and society. Ethical issues in the context of pre-abortion ultrasound, obstetric practices in low-income settings, and keepsake ultrasound imaging were also greatly discussed. Since prenatal ultrasound practices critically impact pregnant people's autonomy and their role within pregnancy, we conclude that information providing strategies should be developed to appropriately inform pregnant people about the nature, purpose, risks, and choices revolving around prenatal ultrasound. In addition, as it is becoming increasingly difficult to separate the social and clinical dimensions of prenatal ultrasound, future research should focus on examining if and how such dimensions should be reconciled.
产前超声是一种非侵入性诊断检查。尽管其诊断价值已得到认可,但这项技术引发了复杂的伦理问题。本研究的目的是提供一项全面分析,连贯地梳理二维和三维产前超声检查所引发的伦理挑战。我们进行了一项系统的文献综述。系统检索了六个数据库。结果凸显出,与行善原则、知情同意和自主性相关的担忧主要与产前超声在临床环境中的常规使用有关,而与妊娠过度医疗化、歧视和胎儿本体论相关的考量则常常是在探讨超声对医学和社会的影响时被提及。堕胎前超声检查背景下的伦理问题、低收入环境中的产科实践以及纪念性超声成像也得到了大量讨论。由于产前超声检查实践严重影响孕妇的自主性及其在妊娠中的角色,我们得出结论,应制定信息提供策略,以便适当地向孕妇告知围绕产前超声的性质、目的、风险和选择。此外,鉴于越来越难以区分产前超声的社会和临床层面,未来的研究应聚焦于考察这些层面是否以及应如何协调一致。