Lapauw Laurence, Rutten Aurélie, Dupont Jolan, Amini Nadjia, Vercauteren Laura, Derrien Muriel, Raes Jeroen, Gielen Evelien
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Division of Gerontology and Geriatrics, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Division of Gerontology and Geriatrics, Zuyderland Medisch Centrum, Sittard, The Netherlands.
J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle. 2024 Dec;15(6):2190-2207. doi: 10.1002/jcsm.13569. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Altered gut microbiota (GM) potentially contribute to development or worsening of sarcopenia through a gut-muscle axis. This systematic review aims to compare GM between persons with sarcopenia or low sarcopenia-defining parameters (muscle mass, strength, and physical performance) to those with preserved muscle status, as well as to clarify possible associations between sarcopenia (-defining parameters) and relative abundance (RA) of GM-taxa or GM-(α- or β) diversity indices, in order to clarify whether there is robust evidence of the existence of a GM signature for sarcopenia. This systematic review was conducted according to the PRISMA-reporting guideline and pre-registered on PROSPERO (CRD42021259597). PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, ClinicalTrials.gov, and Cochrane library were searched until 20 July 2023. Included studies reported on GM and sarcopenia or its defining parameters. Observational studies were included with populations of mean age ≥50 years. Thirty-two studies totalling 10 781 persons (58.56% ♀) were included. Thirteen studies defined sarcopenia as a construct. Nineteen studies reported at least one sarcopenia-defining parameter (muscle mass, strength or physical performance). Studies found different GM-taxa at multiple levels to be significantly associated with sarcopenia (n = 4/6), muscle mass (n = 13/14), strength (n = 7/9), and physical performance (n = 3/3); however, directions of associations were heterogeneous and also conflicting for specific GM-taxa. Regarding β-diversity, studies found GM of persons with sarcopenia, low muscle mass, or low strength to cluster differently compared with persons with preserved muscle status. α-diversity was low in persons with sarcopenia or low muscle mass as compared with those with preserved muscle status, indicating low richness and diversity. In line with this, α-diversity was significantly and positively associated with muscle mass (n = 3/4) and muscle strength (n = 2/3). All reported results were significant (P < 0.05). Persons with sarcopenia and low muscle parameters have less rich and diverse GM and can be separated from persons with preserved muscle mass and function based on GM-composition. Sarcopenia and low muscle parameters are also associated with different GM-taxa at multiple levels, but results were heterogeneous and no causal conclusions could be made due to the cross-sectional design of the studies. This emphasizes the need for uniformly designed cross-sectional and longitudinal trials with appropriate GM confounder control in large samples of persons with sarcopenia and clearly defined core outcome sets in order to further explore changes in GM-taxa and to determine a sarcopenia-specific GM-signature.
肠道微生物群(GM)的改变可能通过肠-肌轴导致肌肉减少症的发生或恶化。本系统评价旨在比较肌肉减少症患者或低肌肉减少症定义参数(肌肉质量、力量和身体表现)与肌肉状态正常者之间的肠道微生物群,并阐明肌肉减少症(定义参数)与肠道微生物分类群的相对丰度(RA)或肠道微生物群(α或β)多样性指数之间可能存在的关联,以明确是否有确凿证据表明存在肌肉减少症的肠道微生物群特征。本系统评价按照PRISMA报告指南进行,并在PROSPERO(CRD42021259597)上进行了预注册。检索了PubMed、Web of Science、Embase、ClinicalTrials.gov和Cochrane图书馆,截至2023年7月20日。纳入研究报告了肠道微生物群与肌肉减少症或其定义参数。纳入平均年龄≥50岁人群的观察性研究。共纳入32项研究,涉及10781人(58.56%为女性)。13项研究将肌肉减少症定义为一种结构。19项研究报告了至少一项肌肉减少症定义参数(肌肉质量、力量或身体表现)。研究发现多个水平上不同的肠道微生物分类群与肌肉减少症(4/6)、肌肉质量(13/14)、力量(7/9)和身体表现(3/3)显著相关;然而关联方向是异质性的,并且对于特定肠道微生物分类群也相互矛盾。关于β多样性,研究发现肌肉减少症患者、低肌肉质量或低力量患者的肠道微生物群与肌肉状态正常者聚类不同。与肌肉状态正常者相比,肌肉减少症患者或低肌肉质量患者的α多样性较低,表明丰富度和多样性较低。与此一致,α多样性与肌肉质量(3/4)和肌肉力量(2/3)显著正相关。所有报告结果均具有显著性(P<0.05)。肌肉减少症患者和低肌肉参数患者的肠道微生物群丰富度和多样性较低,并且基于肠道微生物群组成可与肌肉质量和功能正常者区分开来。肌肉减少症和低肌肉参数在多个水平上也与不同的肠道微生物分类群相关,但由于研究的横断面设计,结果是异质性的,无法得出因果结论。这强调需要在大量肌肉减少症患者中进行统一设计的横断面和纵向试验,并适当控制肠道微生物群混杂因素,以及明确界定核心结局集,以便进一步探索肠道微生物分类群的变化并确定特定于肌肉减少症的肠道微生物群特征。