Modani Aanchal, Gurdak Kristen, Al Neyadi Layla, Smith Melissa E, Kelly Erin, Thorning Helle, Brekke John S, Pahwa Rohini
Silver School of Social Work, New York University, New York, USA.
Phyllis & Harvey Sandler School of Social Work, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, USA.
Community Ment Health J. 2025 Apr;61(3):420-431. doi: 10.1007/s10597-024-01346-8. Epub 2024 Aug 28.
Individuals with serious mental illnesses (SMIs) face safety risks related to their mental health conditions that are often compounded by experiences of trauma, victimization, residence in impoverished neighborhoods, and histories of homelessness. Stigma and safety challenges significantly impact community integration for individuals with SMIs, particularly women, who often bear a disproportionate burden of vulnerability, gender-based stigma, violence, and other inequalities. This study investigates how women with SMIs engage in the meaning-making of their safety and stigma experiences that, in turn, influence their community integration. From a large multi-site study exploring community experiences of racially/ethnically diverse participants with SMIs, a subsample of 28 cis and trans-gender women, who reported experiencing gendered stigma and a lack of safety, were chosen for the current study. The interviews were analyzed using modified principles of Interpretive Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) to understand how women with SMIs made meaning of their safety and stigma encounters in their families, communities, and neighborhoods. IPA analysis resulted in the emergence of themes within a broad category of safety that represented participants' meaning-making about their physical safety and stigma experiences. Specifically, we used the broad themes from an existing framework of safety called 'Navigating Safety' model as sensitizing concepts for our analysis. Physical and psychological aspects of safety for this study were experienced in tandem whereby the women made sense of how their experiences of a lack of physical safety in multiple contexts shaped their sense of self, internalized stigma, and their social relationships. Within the broad theme of physical safety, participants described unsafe neighborhoods, exposure to domestic and intimate partner violence, and vulnerability to sexual violence. Additionally, under psychological safety, we identified how gender-based norms, race and ethnicity, sources of stigma (internalized, familial, and societal), and social isolation contributed to their mental health and social relationships (particularly with family). These findings highlight how the compounding influence of the intersection of multiple stigmatized identities exerts safety challenges on the lives and community experiences of women with SMIs. Focusing on access and affordability of appropriate gender-responsive resources for women, including trauma-informed care, could reduce hospitalizations, mental health symptoms, and stigma so they can safely integrate into their communities.
患有严重精神疾病(SMIs)的个体面临与他们的心理健康状况相关的安全风险,而创伤经历、受害经历、居住在贫困社区以及无家可归史往往会使这些风险更加复杂。耻辱感和安全挑战对患有严重精神疾病的个体,尤其是女性的社区融入产生了重大影响,她们往往承受着不成比例的脆弱性、基于性别的耻辱感、暴力及其他不平等负担。本研究调查了患有严重精神疾病的女性如何对她们的安全和耻辱经历进行意义建构,而这种意义建构反过来又会影响她们的社区融入。从一项探索患有严重精神疾病的不同种族/民族参与者的社区经历的大型多地点研究中,选取了28名顺性别和跨性别女性作为子样本,她们报告经历了基于性别的耻辱感和缺乏安全感,被选入本研究。访谈采用解释现象学分析(IPA)的修正原则进行分析,以了解患有严重精神疾病的女性如何理解她们在家庭、社区和邻里中遭遇的安全和耻辱经历。IPA分析得出了在一个广泛的安全类别中的主题,这些主题代表了参与者对她们的身体安全和耻辱经历的意义建构。具体而言,我们使用了一个现有的名为“驾驭安全”模型的安全框架中的广泛主题作为我们分析的敏感概念。本研究中安全的身体和心理方面是同时体验到的,女性由此理解了她们在多种情境下缺乏身体安全的经历如何塑造了她们的自我意识、内化的耻辱感以及她们的社会关系。在身体安全这一广泛主题中,参与者描述了不安全的社区、遭受家庭和亲密伴侣暴力以及易遭受性暴力的情况。此外,在心理安全方面,我们确定了基于性别的规范、种族和民族、耻辱感来源(内化的、家庭的和社会的)以及社会孤立如何影响她们的心理健康和社会关系(特别是与家人的关系)。这些发现凸显了多种被污名化身份的交叉所产生的复合影响如何给患有严重精神疾病的女性的生活和社区经历带来安全挑战。关注为女性提供适当的性别敏感资源的可及性和可负担性,包括创伤知情护理,可以减少住院次数、心理健康症状和耻辱感,使她们能够安全地融入社区。