Vignola Emilia F, Andrea Sarah B, Hajat Anjum, Weathers Tess D, Ahonen Emily Q
University of Washington School of Public Health, Seattle USA.
Oregon Health & Science University-Portland State University School of Public Health, Portland, USA.
J Crit Public Health. 2024 May 6;1(1):45-60. doi: 10.55016/ojs/jcph.v1i1.78291. Epub 2024 Apr 9.
Disease prevention relies on a complex interplay between social context and individual behaviors. Work and the employment conditions that shape it are key domains where this interplay occurs, a reality highlighted by the COVID-19 pandemic. To explore the links between employment quality and social context as drivers of disease prevention, we conducted a multiple case study of food retail and services workers during COVID-19 in two U.S. states - Indiana and Washington - with differing norms and policy landscapes. We drew on public health surveillance data, government/NGO documents, and media sources to contextualize in-depth interviews with 26 precariously employed food workers. Analysis consisted of a within-case and a cross-case phase, each drawing on state contextual and interview data. Precariously employed food workers in Indiana and Washington had contrasting expectations of employers, government, and public health that we interpret as parallels of policies and norms in their respective states. Workers in both states discussed preventive behaviors in an individualized way, but appeared motivated by different constraints on their choices. Our study points to the importance of explicitly considering employment and the social safety net in public health to better prepare us for the next crisis and ameliorate health inequities under ordinary circumstances.
疾病预防依赖于社会环境与个人行为之间复杂的相互作用。工作以及塑造工作的就业条件是这种相互作用发生的关键领域,新冠疫情突出了这一现实。为了探究作为疾病预防驱动因素的就业质量与社会环境之间的联系,我们对美国印第安纳州和华盛顿州的食品零售和服务业工人在新冠疫情期间进行了多案例研究,这两个州有着不同的规范和政策环境。我们利用公共卫生监测数据、政府/非政府组织文件以及媒体来源,对26名受雇不稳定的食品工人进行了深入访谈并进行背景分析。分析包括案例内和跨案例两个阶段,每个阶段都利用了州背景和访谈数据。印第安纳州和华盛顿州受雇不稳定的食品工人对雇主、政府和公共卫生有着截然不同的期望,我们将其解读为各自州政策和规范的体现。两个州的工人都以个体化的方式讨论预防行为,但他们的选择似乎受到不同因素的制约。我们的研究指出,在公共卫生中明确考虑就业和社会安全网对于让我们更好地为下一次危机做好准备以及在正常情况下改善健康不平等状况具有重要意义。