Macgregor J E, Moss S M, Parkin D M, Day N E
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1985 May 25;290(6481):1543-6. doi: 10.1136/bmj.290.6481.1543.
To estimate the relative risk of invasive cervical cancer in each succeeding year after a negative screening result the screening records of all women tested in the north east of Scotland were examined as the basis for a case-control study. The cases consisted of 115 women in whom invasive cervical cancer had been diagnosed in 1968-82 and who had appeared in the screening records at least once before diagnosis. For each patient five controls were selected from women of the same age who appeared in the screening records before the date of diagnosis in the patient. If the patient's cancer had been detected by screening the controls were chosen from women of the same age screened the same year. A comparison was made between cases and controls of the number of negative smears taken before the diagnosis. The results showed a high relative protection (inverse of the relative risk) in the first two years after a negative test, falling steadily as time since the last negative test elapsed. Even after 10 years, however, a considerable residual effect was observed.
为了评估筛查结果为阴性后的每一年发生浸润性宫颈癌的相对风险,我们检查了苏格兰东北部所有接受检测女性的筛查记录,以此作为一项病例对照研究的基础。病例组由1968年至1982年间被诊断为浸润性宫颈癌且在诊断前至少有一次出现在筛查记录中的115名女性组成。对于每位患者,从在该患者诊断日期之前出现在筛查记录中的同年龄女性中选择5名对照。如果患者的癌症是通过筛查发现的,则对照从同年接受筛查的同年龄女性中选择。比较病例组和对照组在诊断前进行的阴性涂片检查数量。结果显示,在检测结果为阴性后的头两年有较高的相对保护作用(相对风险的倒数),随着自上次阴性检测以来时间的推移,这种保护作用稳步下降。然而,即使在10年后,仍观察到相当大的残余效应。