Pratiwi Hening, Ari Kristina Susi, Wahyuni Widayanti Anna, Suryo Prabandari Yayi
Doctoral Program in Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Yogyakarta, Indonesia.
Department of Pharmacy, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jenderal Soedirman University, Purwokerto, Indonesia.
F1000Res. 2023 Jan 6;12:18. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.127017.1. eCollection 2023.
: Empathy in the context of healthcare is an immersion experience to comprehend patients' viewpoints, feelings, and emotions, without passing judgment, to ensure they receive the necessary treatment to feel comfortable. Empathy for others must be possessed by healthcare professionals and healthcare students as healthcare professionals' candidates, including the pharmacy student. This study aimed to identify and assess the determinants related to pharmacy students' empathy. Three electronic databases were used for the first searches. We used peer-reviewed original papers, full text, must assess determinants that are associated with pharmacy students' empathy, and only be focused on pharmacy students (first to the fourth year) as healthcare professionals candidates. We utilized Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Checklists to observe the quality of published publications and reduce bias. This review examined 14 papers that reported on determinants connected to pharmacy students' empathy. Nine studies evaluated the association between gender or sex and the level of empathy, seven studies reported educational intervention, four studies discussed the year of study, two studies explained the type of school, four studies evaluated experience, and others determinants that discussed in the included studies were career preference, intercultural sensitivity, stigma, altruism, grit, self-awareness, marital status, and family income Educational intervention, experience, gender or sex, type of school, year of study, intercultural sensitivity, career preference, altruism, grit, self-awareness, marital status, and family income, can all have a positive impact on increased empathy among pharmacy students. We acknowledge that the included studies are heterogeneous, indicating that additional studies are necessary before reaching any firm conclusions. More research is needed to properly understand how empathy can be improved with the most effective pharmacy educational strategies. Higher levels of evidence are also required in studies to address the potential bias caused using self-report questionnaires, as well as other potential biases and inaccuracies.
在医疗保健背景下,同理心是一种沉浸式体验,旨在理解患者的观点、感受和情绪,而不进行评判,以确保他们获得必要的治疗并感到舒适。医疗保健专业人员以及作为医疗保健专业人员候选人的医学生,包括药学专业学生,都必须具备对他人的同理心。本研究旨在识别和评估与药学专业学生同理心相关的决定因素。最初使用了三个电子数据库进行检索。我们使用经过同行评审的原创论文全文,必须评估与药学专业学生同理心相关的决定因素,并且仅关注作为医疗保健专业人员候选人的药学专业学生(大一至大四)。我们利用乔安娜·布里格斯循证卫生保健中心的批判性评价清单来观察已发表文献的质量并减少偏差。本综述审查了14篇报告与药学专业学生同理心相关决定因素的论文。九项研究评估了性别与同理心水平之间的关联,七项研究报告了教育干预,四项研究讨论了学习年份,两项研究解释了学校类型,四项研究评估了经验,纳入研究中讨论的其他决定因素包括职业偏好、跨文化敏感性、耻辱感、利他主义、毅力、自我意识、婚姻状况和家庭收入。教育干预、经验、性别、学校类型、学习年份、跨文化敏感性、职业偏好、利他主义、毅力、自我意识、婚姻状况和家庭收入,都可能对提高药学专业学生的同理心产生积极影响。我们承认纳入的研究具有异质性,这表明在得出任何确凿结论之前还需要更多研究。需要更多研究来正确理解如何通过最有效的药学教育策略提高同理心。在研究中还需要更高水平的证据来解决使用自我报告问卷导致的潜在偏差以及其他潜在偏差和不准确之处。