Carmine A A, Brogden R N
Drugs. 1985 Aug;30(2):85-126. doi: 10.2165/00003495-198530020-00001.
Pirenzepine is a 'selective' antimuscarinic agent which, unlike classic anticholinergic agents, inhibits gastric acid secretion at lower doses than are required to affect gastrointestinal motility, salivary, central nervous system, cardiovascular, ocular and urinary functions. On a weight basis, pirenzepine has one-tenth to one-eighth the potency of atropine in inhibiting stimulated gastric acid secretion in humans. Extensive controlled trials utilising endoscopy in outpatients with duodenal ulcers indicate that patient response to pirenzepine is dose related. Doses of 100 to 150 mg/day are superior to placebo in promoting duodenal ulcer healing and in diminishing day and night pain and supplementary antacid consumption. At such doses, the efficacy of pirenzepine appears to be superior to that of gefarnate 300 mg/day and generally not significantly different from that of cimetidine 1 g/day in treating duodenal ulcers. A beneficial effect of pirenzepine in the prevention of duodenal ulcer recurrence was apparent in preliminary studies in small numbers of patients, but its efficacy in this regard needs further confirmation and the optimum dosage determined. Less extensive data on the treatment of benign gastric ulcers suggest that pirenzepine 100 to 150 mg/day is superior to placebo and gefarnate 300 mg/day and does not differ significantly from cimetidine 1 g/day promoting gastric ulcer healing. Pirenzepine is well tolerated by most patients, with a low incidence of typical antimuscarinic effects on the gastrointestinal tract, genitourinary system or heart being reported in clinical studies. However, dry mouth and blurred vision are the more common side effects with clinically effective doses. Thus, pirenzepine appears to have relatively selective antimuscarinic activity, although controlled studies comparing pirenzepine and conventional antimuscarinics in patients with peptic ulcer disease have not been reported.
哌仑西平是一种“选择性”抗毒蕈碱药,与传统抗胆碱能药不同,它在抑制胃酸分泌时所需剂量低于影响胃肠蠕动、唾液分泌、中枢神经系统、心血管、眼部及泌尿功能所需的剂量。按重量计算,哌仑西平抑制人胃酸分泌的效力仅为阿托品的十分之一至八分之一。利用内镜对十二指肠溃疡门诊患者进行的大量对照试验表明,患者对哌仑西平的反应与剂量相关。每日100至150毫克的剂量在促进十二指肠溃疡愈合、减轻日夜疼痛及减少抗酸剂用量方面优于安慰剂。在该剂量下,哌仑西平治疗十二指肠溃疡的疗效似乎优于每日300毫克的吉法酯且通常与每日1克的西咪替丁无显著差异。在少数患者的初步研究中,哌仑西平在预防十二指肠溃疡复发方面有明显有益作用,但其在这方面的疗效尚需进一步证实并确定最佳剂量。关于治疗良性胃溃疡的资料较少,提示每日100至150毫克的哌仑西平优于安慰剂和每日300毫克的吉法酯,且在促进胃溃疡愈合方面与每日1克的西咪替丁无显著差异。大多数患者对哌仑西平耐受性良好,临床研究报道其对胃肠道、泌尿生殖系统或心脏产生典型抗毒蕈碱作用的发生率较低。然而,口干和视物模糊是临床有效剂量时较常见的副作用。因此,哌仑西平似乎具有相对选择性抗毒蕈碱活性,尽管尚未有比较哌仑西平与传统抗毒蕈碱药治疗消化性溃疡病患者的对照研究报道。