Fernandes Tiago, Rago Vincenzo, Castañer Marta, Camerino Oleguer
National Institute of Physical Education of Catalonia, University of Lleida, Lleida, Spain.
Faculty of Health and Sports Sciences, Universidade Europeia, Lisbon, Portugal.
BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med. 2024 Sep 13;10(3):e002196. doi: 10.1136/bmjsem-2024-002196. eCollection 2024.
This study protocol describes a systematic method to identify, collect and rank sports science and medicine interventions most associated with optimising team performance in elite football in observational studies. While numerous interventions, such as conditioning or injury prevention programmes, protective equipment, training periodisation, tactical decision-making, supplements, medication and hydration administration, have been associated with football players and team performance enhancement, there is a need to prioritise them to save resources and increase the efficiency of applications. Nevertheless, previous literature has shown that systematic reviews in elite football often need more protocol registration and have limited procedures, synthesis and practical implications directly applicable to the field. Therefore, this protocol outlines a comprehensive process developed following the Cochrane Collaboration and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement comprising the following stages: (1) research question formulation and preliminary study, (2) eligibility criteria, (3) search strategy, (4) study selection, (5) data collection, (6) data assessment and (7) data synthesis and statistical analysis. It also presents a data quality standard process incorporating human and large language models reviewers and a detailed flow diagram for selecting suitable quantitative synthesis and ranking techniques. It includes meta-regression, pairwise, network, Bayesian or hierarchical meta-analysis options. The project associated and pre-registration of the protocol is available on the Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/tzcxq/).
本研究方案描述了一种系统方法,用于在观察性研究中识别、收集与优化精英足球团队表现最相关的体育科学和医学干预措施,并对其进行排序。虽然许多干预措施,如体能训练或预防伤病计划、防护装备、训练周期安排、战术决策、补充剂、药物和补水管理等,都与足球运动员和团队表现提升有关,但有必要对它们进行优先级排序,以节省资源并提高应用效率。然而,以往文献表明,精英足球领域的系统评价往往缺乏方案注册,且程序、综合分析及直接适用于该领域的实际意义有限。因此,本方案概述了一个依据Cochrane协作网及系统评价与Meta分析的首选报告项目声明制定的全面流程,包括以下阶段:(1)研究问题的提出与初步研究;(2)纳入标准;(3)检索策略;(4)研究选择;(5)数据收集;(6)数据评估;(7)数据综合与统计分析。它还提出了一个纳入人工和大语言模型评审员的数据质量标准流程,以及一个用于选择合适的定量综合与排序技术的详细流程图。它包括元回归、成对、网络、贝叶斯或分层Meta分析选项。该方案相关的项目及预注册可在开放科学框架(https://osf.io/tzcxq/)上获取。