Roy Debendra Nath, Hossen Md Mohabbot, Biswas Mohitosh, Islam Ekramul, Azam Md Shah
Pharmacy department, Jashore University of Science and Technology, Jashore, 7408, Bangladesh.
Institute of Education and Research, University of Rajshahi, Rajshahi, 6205, Bangladesh.
F1000Res. 2022 Aug 12;11:928. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.122815.1. eCollection 2022.
Examining the prevalence of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine hesitancy and understanding what motivates students to accept or reject a newly promoted vaccine has the potential in preventing rapid spread of infection and optimizing country-wide mass vaccination programs. This systematic review aimed to examine global COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among students, and to identify an up-to-date and concise assessment of most common factors influencing vaccine acceptance and hesitancy around the world. A systematic search of peer-reviewed literatures indexed in reputable databases was performed. After obtaining the results via screening using PRISMA flow diagram, a total of 35 articles met the inclusion criteria and formed the basic structure of the study objectives. The results revealed that, the worldwide pooled COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy rate was (x̅%)=29.8% (95% CI 23.37-36.23) among students. According to the country count assessment, the pooled vaccine hesitancy has been found to be ups and downs across the countries around the world such as (x̅%)=32% (95% CI 20.04-43.97) in Asia, (x̅%)=(28.11%, 95% CI 18.83-37.40) in the United States, (x̅%)=15.59% (95% CI 8.23-22.95) in Europe, (x̅%)=55.93% (95% CI 40.31-71.55) in Africa, (x̅%)=20.4% in North America, and (x̅%)=22.5% in multi-ethnic areas in the reported student's COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. In total, 10 key factors were identified. "Side effect" 45.41% (95% CI 29.68-61.14), "safety" 42.27% (95% CI 27.50-57.04), and "trust" 44.95%, (95% CI 26.51-63.39) were the overarching concerns in making student's vaccination decisions. The prevalence of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy varied among the students; however, vaccine acceptance or refusal relies on several socio-psychological, societal, and vaccine related factors. This study helps the vaccine policy-makers and health stakeholders gain a better understanding of COVID-19 vaccination drive and design the vaccine promotion strategies. Health educational interventions could be the most preferred approach to improve student's adherence and knowledge about the COVID-19 vaccination consequences.
研究冠状病毒病(COVID-19)疫苗犹豫的流行情况,并了解促使学生接受或拒绝新推广疫苗的因素,对于预防感染的快速传播和优化全国范围的大规模疫苗接种计划具有重要意义。本系统评价旨在研究全球学生中对COVID-19疫苗的犹豫情况,并对影响全球疫苗接受度和犹豫程度的最常见因素进行最新、简明的评估。我们对知名数据库中索引的同行评审文献进行了系统检索。通过使用PRISMA流程图进行筛选获得结果后,共有35篇文章符合纳入标准,构成了研究目标的基本框架。结果显示,全球学生中COVID-19疫苗犹豫率的合并值为(x̅%)=29.8%(95%置信区间23.37 - 36.23)。根据国家计数评估,全球各国的合并疫苗犹豫率有起有伏,例如亚洲为(x̅%)=32%(95%置信区间20.04 - 43.97),美国为(x̅%)=(28.11%,95%置信区间18.83 - 37.40),欧洲为(x̅%)=15.59%(95%置信区间8.23 - 22.95),非洲为(x̅%)=55.93%(95%置信区间40.31 - 71.55),北美为(x̅%)=20.4%,多民族地区为(x̅%)=22.5%,这些均为报告的学生对COVID-19疫苗的犹豫率。总共确定了10个关键因素。“副作用”占45.41%(95%置信区间29.68 - 61.14),“安全性”占42.27%(95%置信区间27.50 - 57.04),“信任”占44.95%(95%置信区间26.51 - 63.39),这些是影响学生疫苗接种决策的主要担忧因素。COVID-19疫苗犹豫在学生中的流行情况各不相同;然而,疫苗的接受或拒绝取决于若干社会心理、社会和与疫苗相关的因素。本研究有助于疫苗政策制定者和卫生利益相关者更好地理解COVID-19疫苗接种工作,并设计疫苗推广策略。健康教育干预可能是提高学生对COVID-19疫苗接种后果的依从性和认识的最优选方法。