Zain Mohd Aizat, Suhaimi Julia, Dahlui Maznah, Goh Hong Ching, Then Amy Yee-Hui, Yakub Nur Asyikin, Noor Mohd Iqbal Mohd, Garside Ruth, Eales Jacqualyn, Jose Edgar, Kari Fatimah
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Built Environment, Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Department of Basic Health Sciences, Faculty of Pharmacy, MAHSA University, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Environ Evid. 2022 Feb 4;11(1):2. doi: 10.1186/s13750-022-00255-1.
Many conservation management interventions have been set up to bring win-win outcomes for both biodiversity conservation and the well-being of the local communities. Nevertheless, the implementation process of marine protected areas (MPAs) can generate unexpected outcomes and fail to reach its objectives in addressing communities' challenges. Therefore, it is crucial to have a better understanding of how MPAs influence the socioeconomic aspects of the coastal communities. This paper describes the protocol to conduct a systematic review which aims to explore and review the evidence that reflects the outcomes of marine site protection on poverty reduction in terms of economic and material living standards among the coastal communities in Southeast Asia. The review question is "What are the outcomes of marine site protection implementation on poverty in terms of material and economic living standards of coastal communities in Southeast Asia?".
The systematic review uses rigorous search strategies and selection methods based on pre-defined eligibility criteria to identify and examine published journal articles and grey literature that are available on the review topic. Relevant studies and grey literature will be extracted from a recent systematic map of the evidence documenting the effect of marine or coastal nature conservation or natural resource management activities on human well-being in Southeast Asia. We will search online databases including Web of Science Core Collection, Ovid Medline, Environmental Complete, Scopus, as well as Google Scholar and sources of grey literature for any additional literature available since the evidence map was created. For this review, the populations of interest are from coastal communities in the Southeast Asia region. Comparators to marine site protection will be no intervention and/or pre-MPA implementation. The economic and material living standards, which are the poverty domains, will be evaluated as outcomes. Once we have identified relevant literature, we will perform a critical appraisal, data extraction, and synthesis appropriate to the type of literature found, to investigate the effect of marine site protection on poverty reduction.
许多保护管理干预措施已被设立,旨在为生物多样性保护和当地社区福祉带来双赢结果。然而,海洋保护区(MPA)的实施过程可能会产生意想不到的结果,并且在应对社区挑战方面未能实现其目标。因此,更好地了解海洋保护区如何影响沿海社区的社会经济方面至关重要。本文描述了进行系统评价的方案,该评价旨在探索和审查反映东南亚沿海社区海洋区域保护在经济和物质生活水平方面减贫成果的证据。评价问题是“就东南亚沿海社区的物质和经济生活水平而言,海洋区域保护实施在减贫方面的成果是什么?”。
该系统评价采用基于预先定义的纳入标准的严格检索策略和筛选方法,以识别和审查关于该评价主题的已发表期刊文章和灰色文献。相关研究和灰色文献将从最近一份记录海洋或沿海自然保护或自然资源管理活动对东南亚人类福祉影响的证据系统地图中提取。我们将检索在线数据库,包括科学引文索引核心合集、Ovid 医学数据库、环境全文数据库、Scopus,以及谷歌学术,并检索灰色文献来源,以获取自证据地图创建以来的任何其他可用文献。对于本评价,感兴趣的人群来自东南亚地区的沿海社区。海洋区域保护的对照将是无干预和/或海洋保护区实施前的情况。作为贫困领域的经济和物质生活水平将作为结果进行评估。一旦我们确定了相关文献,我们将根据所发现文献的类型进行批判性评价、数据提取和综合,以研究海洋区域保护对减贫的影响。