Kiya Yukitaka, Watanabe Saori, Harada Kana, Yui Hideki, Yashiro Yoshimi, Muto Kaori
Department of Public Policy, Institute of Medical Science, University of Tokyo, Japan.
Waseda University, School of Law, Japan.
Regen Ther. 2024 Sep 20;26:831-836. doi: 10.1016/j.reth.2024.09.005. eCollection 2024 Jun.
When the International Society for Stem Cell Research revised its 2021 guidelines, it reversed its ban on the culture of human embryos beyond 14 days. However, despite widespread recognition of the importance of public debate on embryo research, it remains unclear how patients who have undergone in vitro fertilization (IVF) and/or intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) perceive this change in the guidelines. Three focus group interviews were conducted with IVF/ICSI patients to understand their opinions on extending the in vitro culture of human embryos beyond 14 days. Thematic analysis revealed a primarily favorable attitude toward the extension of in vitro embryo culture, identifying six reasons for this positive perspective. However, two reasons for negative attitudes were identified, along with some concerns that need to be addressed. To facilitate an open discussion, the following suggestions were made to the government and scientific community. The government and scientific community should provide sufficient knowledge to IVF/ICSI patients about research before discussions. It's important to consider diverse views on embryo models, including distrust and resistance. Ensuring IVF/ICSI patients' psychological safety is essential. "Public conversations" with citizens, including IVF/ICSI patients, should be promoted, and their opinions should be considered as part of a broader public spectrum.
当国际干细胞研究学会修订其2021年指南时,取消了对人类胚胎超过14天培养的禁令。然而,尽管人们普遍认识到公众对胚胎研究进行辩论的重要性,但接受过体外受精(IVF)和/或卵胞浆内单精子注射(ICSI)的患者如何看待该指南中的这一变化仍不清楚。对接受IVF/ICSI治疗的患者进行了三次焦点小组访谈,以了解他们对将人类胚胎体外培养延长至14天以上的看法。主题分析显示,他们对延长体外胚胎培养主要持支持态度,并确定了形成这种积极看法的六个原因。然而,也确定了两个持消极态度的原因,以及一些需要解决的担忧。为了促进公开讨论,向政府和科学界提出了以下建议。政府和科学界应在讨论前向接受IVF/ICSI治疗的患者提供足够的研究知识。重要的是要考虑对胚胎模型的各种观点,包括不信任和抵制。确保接受IVF/ICSI治疗的患者的心理安全至关重要。应促进与包括接受IVF/ICSI治疗的患者在内的公民进行“公众对话”,并应将他们的意见作为更广泛公众观点的一部分加以考虑。