Division of Emergency Medicine, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of Emergency Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Western University, London, ON, Canada.
CJEM. 2024 Nov;26(11):797-803. doi: 10.1007/s43678-024-00779-0. Epub 2024 Sep 30.
This study aimed to understand current prehospital trauma air-ambulance policies and triage guidelines across Canada. The research question centered on understanding the guidelines used by provinces and territories and identifying potential regional variations in air-ambulance triage.
We conducted a cross-sectional survey from November 2022 to May 2023, involving trauma leaders from Canada's 13 provinces and territories. Participants were identified via the Trauma Association of Canada and professional networks. The survey, developed with expert input and pilot tested for clarity, focused on prehospital trauma-triage guidelines, level of adoption of Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) triage guidelines, and auto-launch air-ambulance policies. Data were collected using an 18-item electronic survey. Potential response bias was considered, and confidentiality was maintained. A cross-sectional qualitative analysis was used to evaluate the guidelines' adoption and variations, with responses compared across regions.
The analysis revealed a nationwide adoption (11 of 11 respondents) of the CDC guidelines, indicating a standardized approach to patient transportation. Notably, many provinces and territories (5 of 11) endorse auto-launch protocols for air ambulances in specific scenarios. These policies offer advantages in geographically vast regions weighed against the cost of over-triage and inefficient resource allocation. Each province and territory tailors its approach based on factors such as geographic areas served, and available resources.
This study provides a snapshot of the current state of prehospital trauma-triage guidelines in Canada. With some differences in nomenclature, Canadian provinces and territories widely apply the CDC guidelines to serve their populations. There is some regional variation on how transport is initiated within their borders. The findings underscore the delicate balance required for optimizing air-ambulance policies, considering factors such as timely access, resource allocation, and the local application of guidelines.
本研究旨在了解加拿大当前的院前创伤空中救护政策和分诊指南。研究问题集中在了解各省和地区使用的指南,并确定空中救护分诊中潜在的区域差异。
我们于 2022 年 11 月至 2023 年 5 月进行了一项横断面调查,涉及加拿大 13 个省和地区的创伤领域的领导者。参与者是通过加拿大创伤协会和专业网络确定的。该调查是在专家的投入下制定的,并进行了清晰性试点测试,重点关注院前创伤分诊指南、采用疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)分诊指南的程度,以及自动启动空中救护政策。使用 18 项电子调查收集数据。考虑到潜在的反应偏差,并保持机密性。采用横断面定性分析评估指南的采用和变化,比较各地区的反应。
分析结果显示,全国范围内(11 名受访者中的 11 名)采用了 CDC 指南,表明对患者运输采用了标准化方法。值得注意的是,许多省份和地区(11 个中的 5 个)在特定情况下支持空中救护的自动启动协议。这些政策在权衡过度分诊和资源分配效率低下的成本方面,在地域辽阔的地区具有优势。每个省和地区都根据所服务的地理区域和可用资源等因素来调整其方法。
本研究提供了加拿大院前创伤分诊指南现状的快照。加拿大各省和地区在名称上存在一些差异,但广泛应用 CDC 指南为其民众服务。在如何在其边界内启动运输方面存在一些区域差异。这些发现强调了在优化空中救护政策时需要权衡的微妙平衡,考虑到及时获得、资源分配和指南的当地应用等因素。