Braczko Felix, Skyschally Andreas, Lieder Helmut, Kather Jakob Nikolas, Kleinbongard Petra, Heusch Gerd
Institute for Pathophysiology, West German Heart and Vascular Center, University of Duisburg-Essen, Hufelandstr. 55, 45122, Essen, Germany.
Department of Medicine III, University Hospital RWTH Aachen, Aachen, Germany.
Basic Res Cardiol. 2024 Dec;119(6):923-936. doi: 10.1007/s00395-024-01081-x. Epub 2024 Sep 30.
Infarct size (IS) is the most robust end point for evaluating the success of preclinical studies on cardioprotection. The gold standard for IS quantification in ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) experiments is triphenyl tetrazolium chloride (TTC) staining, typically done manually. This study aimed to determine if automation through deep learning segmentation is a time-saving and valid alternative to standard IS quantification. High-resolution images from TTC-stained, macroscopic heart slices were retrospectively collected from pig experiments (n = 390) with I/R without/with cardioprotection to cover a wide IS range. Existing IS data from pig experiments, quantified using a standard method of manual and subsequent digital labeling of film-scan annotations, were used as reference. To automate the evaluation process with the aim to be more objective and save time, a deep learning pipeline was implemented; the collected images (n = 3869) were pre-processed by cropping and labeled (image annotations). To ensure their usability as training data for a deep learning segmentation model, IS was quantified from image annotations and compared to IS quantified using the existing film-scan annotations. A supervised deep learning segmentation model based on dynamic U-Net architecture was developed and trained. The evaluation of the trained model was performed by fivefold cross-validation (n = 220 experiments) and testing on an independent test set (n = 170 experiments). Performance metrics (Dice similarity coefficient [DSC], pixel accuracy [ACC], average precision [mAP]) were calculated. IS was then quantified from predictions and compared to IS quantified from image annotations (linear regression, Pearson's r; analysis of covariance; Bland-Altman plots). Performance metrics near 1 indicated a strong model performance on cross-validated data (DSC: 0.90, ACC: 0.98, mAP: 0.90) and on the test set data (DSC: 0.89, ACC: 0.98, mAP: 0.93). IS quantified from predictions correlated well with IS quantified from image annotations in all data sets (cross-validation: r = 0.98; test data set: r = 0.95) and analysis of covariance identified no significant differences. The model reduced the IS quantification time per experiment from approximately 90 min to 20 s. The model was further tested on a preliminary test set from experiments in isolated, saline-perfused rat hearts with regional I/R without/with cardioprotection (n = 27). There was also no significant difference in IS between image annotations and predictions, but the performance on the test set data from rat hearts was lower (DSC: 0.66, ACC: 0.91, mAP: 0.65). IS quantification using a deep learning segmentation model is a valid and time-efficient alternative to manual and subsequent digital labeling.
梗死面积(IS)是评估心脏保护临床前研究成功与否的最可靠终点指标。在缺血/再灌注(I/R)实验中,IS定量的金标准是氯化三苯基四氮唑(TTC)染色,通常采用手工操作。本研究旨在确定通过深度学习分割实现的自动化是否是标准IS定量的一种省时且有效的替代方法。从猪实验(n = 390)中回顾性收集TTC染色的宏观心脏切片的高分辨率图像,这些实验包括有/无心脏保护的I/R,以涵盖广泛的IS范围。使用手工及随后对胶片扫描注释进行数字标记的标准方法对猪实验的现有IS数据进行定量,将其用作参考。为了使评估过程自动化以更客观并节省时间,实施了一个深度学习流程;对收集到的图像(n = 3869)进行裁剪预处理并进行标记(图像注释)。为确保其可用作深度学习分割模型的训练数据,从图像注释中对IS进行定量,并与使用现有胶片扫描注释定量的IS进行比较。开发并训练了一种基于动态U-Net架构的监督式深度学习分割模型。通过五折交叉验证(n = 220个实验)和在独立测试集(n = 170个实验)上进行测试对训练后的模型进行评估。计算性能指标(骰子相似系数[DSC]、像素准确率[ACC]、平均精度[mAP])。然后根据预测结果对IS进行定量,并与从图像注释中定量的IS进行比较(线性回归、皮尔逊相关系数r;协方差分析;布兰德-奥特曼图)。接近1的性能指标表明模型在交叉验证数据(DSC:0.90,ACC:0.98,mAP:0.90)和测试集数据(DSC:0.89,ACC:0.98,mAP:0.93)上具有较强的性能。在所有数据集中,根据预测结果定量的IS与根据图像注释定量的IS具有良好的相关性(交叉验证:r = 0.98;测试数据集:r = 0.95),协方差分析未发现显著差异。该模型将每个实验的IS定量时间从约90分钟减少到20秒。该模型在来自离体盐水灌注大鼠心脏区域I/R有/无心脏保护实验(n = 27)的初步测试集上进一步测试。图像注释和预测结果之间的IS也没有显著差异,但大鼠心脏测试集数据的性能较低(DSC:0.66,ACC:0.91,mAP:0.65)。使用深度学习分割模型进行IS定量是手工及随后数字标记的一种有效且省时的替代方法。