Katyal Roohi, Sheikh Irfan S, Hadjinicolaou Aristides, Abath Christina Briscoe, Wirrell Elaine C, Reddy Shilpa B, Beniczky Sándor, Nascimento Fábio A
From the Department of Neurology (R.K.), Louisiana State University Health Shreveport, LA; Department of Neurology (I.S.S.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA; Department of Neurology (A.H.), CHU Sainte-Justine, Universite de Montreal, Canada; Department of Neurology (C.B.A.), Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA; Department of Neurology (E.C.W.), Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN; Department of Neurology (S.B.R.), Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville, TN; Department of Clinical Neurophysiology (S.B.), Danish Epilepsy Center, Dianalund and Aarhus University Hospital; Department of Clinical Medicine (S.B.), Aarhus University, Denmark; and Department of Neurology (F.A.N.), Washington University School of Medicine St. Louis, MO.
Neurol Educ. 2024 Jan 5;3(1):e200112. doi: 10.1212/NE9.0000000000200112. eCollection 2024 Mar.
In the United States, many child neurologists (CNs) and neurodevelopmental disability (NDD) specialists who read EEGs in clinical practice had no additional EEG training other than what was received during residency. This practice highlights the importance of ensuring that CN/NDD residents achieve EEG competence before graduation. However, prior survey-based evidence showed that roughly a third of graduating CN residents in the United States do not feel confident interpreting EEGs independently. As part of a needs assessment, we conducted a descriptive study characterizing EEG practices in CN and NDD residency programs in the United States and Canada.
A 30-question e-survey focused on characteristics of residency programs and their EEG teaching practices was sent to all 88 CN and NDD residency program directors listed in the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, Child Neurology Society, and Canadian Residency Matching Service websites.
Twenty-nine (n = 29/88; 33%) residency programs completed the survey, most of which were CN (90%), academic (90%), and located in the United States (83%). The mean number of weeks dedicated to EEG training required to graduate was 7.3 ± 4 (mean ± SD). EEG rotations involved the clinic/outpatient setting (83%), epilepsy monitoring unit (EMU) (76%), and inpatient setting (excluding EMU) (72%). During a 4-week EEG rotation, residents typically read 16-45 EEGs (62%). The most common methods of EEG teaching in CN/NDD programs were teaching during EEG rotation and yearly didactics. The mean number of EEGs read per rotation had a significant positive correlation with the average percentage of residents who reportedly achieve EEG competence by graduation (coefficient 0.461; = 0.007). Barriers to EEG education were reported by 28% of the programs; the most common barrier identified was insufficient EEG exposure. Possible solutions were primarily related to increasing quality and quantity of EEG exposure. Almost two-thirds of programs reported not using objective measures to assess EEG competence.
Our results characterize resident EEG education in a third of CN/NDD residency programs in the United States and Canada. We suggest that residency leaderships consider standardization of EEG learning along with establishment and implementation of objective measures in training requirements and competence assessment.
在美国,许多在临床实践中解读脑电图的儿童神经科医生(CNs)和神经发育障碍(NDD)专家,除了住院医师培训期间接受的培训外,没有接受过额外的脑电图培训。这种做法凸显了确保CN/NDD住院医师在毕业前具备脑电图解读能力的重要性。然而,先前基于调查的证据表明,美国约三分之一即将毕业的CN住院医师对独立解读脑电图缺乏信心。作为需求评估的一部分,我们开展了一项描述性研究,以描述美国和加拿大CN及NDD住院医师培训项目中的脑电图实践情况。
向研究生医学教育认证委员会、儿童神经学会和加拿大住院医师匹配服务网站列出的所有88个CN和NDD住院医师培训项目主任发送了一份包含30个问题的电子调查问卷,重点关注住院医师培训项目的特点及其脑电图教学实践。
29个(n = 29/88;33%)住院医师培训项目完成了调查,其中大多数是CN项目(90%)、学术项目(90%),且位于美国(83%)。毕业所需的脑电图培训平均周数为7.3±4(均值±标准差)。脑电图轮转涉及门诊/门诊环境(83%)、癫痫监测单元(EMU)(76%)和住院环境(不包括EMU)(72%)。在为期4周的脑电图轮转期间,住院医师通常解读16 - 45份脑电图(62%)。CN/NDD项目中最常见的脑电图教学方法是在脑电图轮转期间教学和年度教学。每次轮转解读的脑电图平均数量与据报道毕业时具备脑电图解读能力的住院医师平均百分比呈显著正相关(系数0.461;P = 0.007)。28%的项目报告了脑电图教育的障碍;最常见的障碍是脑电图接触不足。可能的解决方案主要与增加脑电图接触的质量和数量有关。近三分之二的项目报告未使用客观指标来评估脑电图解读能力。
我们的结果描述了美国和加拿大三分之一的CN/NDD住院医师培训项目中的住院医师脑电图教育情况。我们建议住院医师培训项目领导层考虑脑电图学习的标准化,以及在培训要求和能力评估中建立和实施客观指标。