Clinical Studies and Trials Unit, Division of Development Research, Indian Council of Medical Research, New Delhi, India.
Department of Global Public Health, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Indian J Med Res. 2024 May;159(5):410-420. doi: 10.25259/ijmr_945_23.
Background & objectives Medication-related harm is known to be the cause for about 1/10th of hospitalizations. Some estimates from India show that about 90 per cent of medicines consumed are inessential or irrational and contribute towards high out-of-pocket expenditure on health. In this context, the Indian Council of Medical Research in 2022 constituted a National Task Force (NTF) to explore possible solutions that could improve safe and rational use of medicines (SRUMs). The objective of this study was to identify research ideas in the field of SRUM through a survey of relevant stakeholders, and further to prioritize the research ideas using a pre-identified set of criteria. Methods The responses from the identified stakeholders were assessed using the Child Health and Nutrition Research Initiative method, which is an established research priority-setting methodology. First, the NTF asked for two to six research ideas from relevant Indian and global stakeholders on solutions to improve SRUM. The ideas were checked for duplicates, re-phrased where necessary and classified into various sub-themes. Subsequently, the research ideas were scored by Indian experts with relevant technical expertise using a pre-defined set of five criteria: innovativeness, effectiveness, translational value, answerability and applicability. Each research idea received from a stakeholder was assigned a score under each of the five criteria. The overall research priority score was calculated as a mean of all five criteria-specific scores and converted into a percentage. Results The final output of the prioritization process was a list of research ideas or questions, ranked by their scores. Total 209 unique ideas were received from 190 respondents, which were scored by 27 experts. The top three research topics on medication safety focused on cost-effective strategies for improving antimicrobial stewardship, safe use of poly-pharmacy in geriatric patients and drug take-back policy interventions. Regarding the rational use of medicine, the top three topics included testing mobile application-based antimicrobial stewardship interventions, development of diagnostics for antimicrobial resistance, and behavioural interventions. Interpretation & conclusions Several priority ideas found in this study also align with those of global priority, e.g., safe disposal practices and enhanced pharmacovigilance, rational use of medicines. Patient engagement, which underlines many of the top scoring ideas found in this study, is also inclined with the top research priorities reported by the WHO priority exercise on research into the safe use of medicines. However, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first such work from a low- and middle- income country on medication safety and rational use of medicines. The findings of this research priority-setting exercise can help to guide research for the development of policy-relevant and novel interventions to improve SRUM in India.
背景与目的
据了解,药物相关伤害是导致约十分之一住院治疗的原因。印度的一些估计显示,约 90%的消耗药物是不必要或不合理的,这导致了医疗保健方面的高额自付支出。在这种情况下,印度医学研究理事会于 2022 年成立了一个国家工作队(NTF),以探索可能有助于提高药物安全合理使用(SRUM)的解决方案。本研究的目的是通过调查相关利益攸关方,确定 SRUM 领域的研究思路,并使用预先确定的一套标准对研究思路进行优先排序。
方法
通过使用既定的研究重点制定方法——儿童健康和营养研究倡议方法,对确定的利益攸关方的回复进行评估。首先,NTF 向相关的印度和全球利益攸关方询问了改善 SRUM 的解决方案,要求他们提出两到六个研究思路。对思路进行重复项检查,必要时重新措辞,并分为不同的子主题。随后,印度专家使用预先确定的五套标准对具有相关技术专长的研究思路进行评分:创新性、有效性、转化价值、可回答性和适用性。每个利益攸关方提出的研究思路在五个标准下都有一个得分。从每个利益攸关方收到的研究思路的总体研究优先级分数是所有五个标准特定分数的平均值,并转换为百分比。
结果
优先排序过程的最终结果是一份按分数排序的研究思路或问题清单。从 190 位受访者那里共收到 209 个独特的想法,由 27 位专家进行评分。药物安全方面的前三个研究主题集中在提高抗菌药物管理的成本效益策略、老年患者多药物安全使用和药品回收政策干预上。关于合理用药,前三个主题包括测试基于移动应用的抗菌药物管理干预措施、开发针对抗生素耐药性的诊断方法和行为干预。
结论与解释
本研究中的一些优先研究思路也与全球优先事项一致,例如安全处置做法和加强药物警戒、合理使用药物。患者参与,这也是本研究中许多得分较高的研究思路的基础,也与世界卫生组织关于安全使用药物的研究优先事项报告中的最高研究重点相一致。然而,据我们所知,这是来自中低收入国家的第一个关于药物安全和合理用药的此类工作。本研究重点制定工作的结果可以帮助指导研究,制定与政策相关的创新干预措施,以改善印度的 SRUM。