Johnson Adiv A, Shokhirev Maxim N
Tally Health, New York City, New York, USA.
Aging Cell. 2024 Dec;23(12):e14377. doi: 10.1111/acel.14377. Epub 2024 Oct 11.
Usage of the phrase "biological age" has picked up considerably since the advent of aging clocks and it has become commonplace to describe an aging clock's output as biological age. In contrast to this labeling, biological age is also often depicted as a more abstract concept that helps explain how individuals are aging internally, externally, and functionally. Given that the bulk of molecular aging is tissue-specific and aging itself is a remarkably complex, multifarious process, it is unsurprising that most surveyed scientists agree that aging cannot be quantified via a single metric. We share this sentiment and argue that, just like it would not be reasonable to assume that an individual with an ideal grip strength, VO max, or any other aging biomarker is biologically young, we should be careful not to conflate an aging clock with whole-body biological aging. To address this, we recommend that researchers describe the output of an aging clock based on the type of input data used or the name of the clock itself. Epigenetic aging clocks produce epigenetic age, transcriptomic aging clocks produce transcriptomic age, and so forth. If a clock has a unique name, such as our recently developed epigenetic aging clock CheekAge, the name of the clock can double as the output. As a compromise solution, aging biomarkers can be described as indicators of biological age. We feel that these recommendations will help scientists and the public differentiate between aging biomarkers and the much more elusive concept of biological age.
自衰老时钟问世以来,“生物学年龄”这一表述的使用频率大幅上升,将衰老时钟的输出结果描述为生物学年龄已变得司空见惯。与这种标签化不同,生物学年龄也常被描绘成一个更为抽象的概念,有助于解释个体在内部、外部和功能方面是如何衰老的。鉴于大部分分子衰老具有组织特异性,且衰老本身是一个极其复杂、多方面的过程,大多数接受调查的科学家认为衰老无法通过单一指标进行量化也就不足为奇了。我们认同这一观点,并认为,正如假设一个握力理想、最大摄氧量理想或具有任何其他衰老生物标志物的个体在生物学上还年轻是不合理的一样,我们应谨慎避免将衰老时钟与全身生物学衰老混为一谈。为解决这一问题,我们建议研究人员根据所使用的输入数据类型或时钟本身的名称来描述衰老时钟的输出结果。表观遗传衰老时钟产生表观遗传年龄,转录组衰老时钟产生转录组年龄,依此类推。如果一个时钟有独特的名称,比如我们最近开发的表观遗传衰老时钟CheekAge,那么时钟的名称就可以兼作输出结果。作为一种折衷方案,衰老生物标志物可被描述为生物学年龄的指标。我们认为这些建议将有助于科学家和公众区分衰老生物标志物与更为难以捉摸的生物学年龄概念。