Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of California Davis, Davis, California, USA.
Institute for Global Nutrition, Department of Nutrition, University of California Davis, Davis, California, USA.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2024 Nov;1541(1):181-201. doi: 10.1111/nyas.15234. Epub 2024 Oct 21.
Food and condiment fortification programs are needed to address micronutrient deficiencies and their health, developmental, and mortality consequences; but these programs are never free. Knowing program costs and their allocation across stakeholders is essential to design and manage effective, efficient, and sustainable programs. We developed 10-year hypothetical bouillon fortification program cost models for Nigeria, Senegal, and Burkina Faso that included start-up and operational costs for government and industry, as well as premix costs generated by an embedded premix cost calculator to allow for alternative premix formulas in cost calculations. The main drivers of total costs were total bouillon consumption and the types and amounts of fortificants in the micronutrient premix. For a premix that meets 30% of Codex Nutrient Reference Values in 2.5 g of bouillon for vitamin A, folate, vitamin B12, zinc, and iron, the cost per metric ton of fortified bouillon was ∼$325 for all countries (∼$0.01 per 2.5 g serving). Annual start-up costs ranged from ∼$324k (Burkina Faso) to ∼$455k (Nigeria); nonpremix annual operating costs ranged from ∼$108k (Burkina Faso) to ∼$3.9m (Nigeria); and annual premix costs varied from ∼$2.4m (Burkina Faso) to ∼$76m (Nigeria). In policy discussions, program costs should be set alongside nutritional benefits.
需要通过食品和调味品强化计划来解决微量营养素缺乏及其对健康、发育和死亡率的影响;但这些计划并非免费的。了解计划成本及其在利益相关者之间的分配情况对于设计和管理有效、高效和可持续的计划至关重要。我们为尼日利亚、塞内加尔和布基纳法索开发了为期十年的肉汤强化计划成本模型,其中包括政府和企业的启动和运营成本,以及嵌入式预混料成本计算器生成的预混料成本,以允许在成本计算中使用替代预混料配方。总成本的主要驱动因素是肉汤总消费量和微量营养素预混料中强化剂的类型和数量。对于在 2.5 克肉汤中满足 30%的法典营养素参考值的预混料,用于维生素 A、叶酸、维生素 B12、锌和铁的强化肉汤的每吨成本约为 325 美元(所有国家/地区均为 0.01 美元/2.5 克份)。每年的启动成本从 32.4 万美元(布基纳法索)到 455 万美元(尼日利亚)不等;非预混料每年的运营成本从 10.8 万美元(布基纳法索)到 390 万美元(尼日利亚)不等;每年的预混料成本从 240 万美元(布基纳法索)到 7600 万美元(尼日利亚)不等。在政策讨论中,应将计划成本与营养效益一并考虑。