Univ Rouen Normandie, CRFDP UR 7475, Rouen, France.
Womens Health (Lond). 2024 Jan-Dec;20:17455057241290895. doi: 10.1177/17455057241290895.
Menstrual health represents an interdisciplinary concern that necessitates a broad, integrated understanding beyond its biological foundations, encompassing social, psychological, and cultural dimensions. This study examines whether the corpus of scientific literature from 1970 to 2023 aligns with this holistic perspective by exploring the evolving paradigms within menstrual health. Grounded in Kuhn's theoretical framework, the research delves into thematic shifts, author collaborations, and international partnerships that have emerged over the decades. Utilizing advanced text-mining methodologies, we analyzed a dataset of 34,854 documents obtained from Institute for Scientific Information Web of Science and PubMed in September 2023. These documents were processed through deduplication and data cleaning to ensure accuracy. The study employs a combination of univariate analyses, correspondence factor analyses, hierarchical cluster analyses, and network analyses to uncover insights into thematic evolution and collaborative dynamics within menstrual health research. Thematic analysis reveals three distinct periods in menstrual health research, depicting evolving paradigms. In the first period (1970-1996), the focus was on reproductive health, infertility treatments, hormonal regulation, and epidemiology. The second period (1997-2017) witnesses a transition, emphasizing menstrual health and social inequalities, gynecological studies, and contraception. The third period (2018-2023) maintains a focus on contraception and reproductive health but introduces a pronounced psychological dimension, emphasizing menstrual disorders, gynecological surgery, and socioeconomic concerns. Collaboration analysis indicates increased connectivity, consolidation of researcher communities, and a shift toward interdisciplinary approaches. While international collaborations demonstrate global commitment, geographical concentration prompts questions about paradigm universality. The study shows the existence and evolution of the menstrual health paradigm. Findings suggest a trajectory toward paradigmatic inscription, marked by heightened collaboration and global commitment. Acknowledging the pivotal role of biological aspects, the study underscores the need for a balanced, holistic understanding of menstrual health. Continued efforts are essential to tailor interventions, foster inclusivity, and honor diverse cultural and psychological realities related to menstruation.
月经健康代表了一个跨学科的关注点,需要超越其生物学基础,广泛而综合地理解,包括社会、心理和文化层面。本研究通过探索月经健康中不断发展的范式,考察 1970 年至 2023 年期间的科学文献是否符合这一整体视角。该研究以库恩的理论框架为基础,深入研究了几十年来出现的主题转变、作者合作和国际合作。研究团队利用先进的文本挖掘方法,分析了 2023 年 9 月从 Institute for Scientific Information Web of Science 和 PubMed 获得的 34854 篇文献的数据集。这些文献经过去重和数据清理,以确保准确性。该研究采用单变量分析、对应因子分析、层次聚类分析和网络分析相结合的方法,揭示了月经健康研究中主题演变和合作动态的见解。主题分析揭示了月经健康研究的三个不同阶段,描绘了不断发展的范式。在第一个阶段(1970-1996 年),重点是生殖健康、不孕治疗、激素调节和流行病学。第二个阶段(1997-2017 年)见证了从强调月经健康和社会不平等、妇科研究和避孕的转变。第三个阶段(2018-2023 年)继续关注避孕和生殖健康,但引入了明显的心理维度,强调月经失调、妇科手术和社会经济问题。合作分析表明连接性增强,研究人员社区的整合,以及向跨学科方法的转变。虽然国际合作表明了全球承诺,但地理集中引发了对范式普遍性的质疑。研究表明月经健康范式的存在和演变。研究结果表明,存在朝着范式的轨迹,其特征是合作加强和全球承诺。该研究承认生物学方面的关键作用,强调需要对月经健康进行平衡、综合的理解。需要继续努力,以便调整干预措施、促进包容性,并尊重与月经相关的各种文化和心理现实。