Basch Corey H, Yousaf Helen, Fera Joseph, Castillo Rafael Gonzalez
Department of Public Health, William Paterson University, University Hall, Wayne, NJ, 07470, USA.
Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University NY, NY, 10032, USA.
J Community Health. 2025 Apr;50(2):280-286. doi: 10.1007/s10900-024-01415-9. Epub 2024 Oct 25.
Social listening can provide deeper insight into public sentiment regarding policy proposals, as seen with the congestion pricing initiative in New York City (NYC). The purpose of this study was to assess the content of a sample of TikTok videos related to congestion pricing in NYC. A total of 100 unique videos were extracted from the hashtag #nyccongestionpricing on TikTok and coded for the presence of the following information based on four different areas of focus: video metrics, details about pricing plan, effects of pricing plan, and user-related issues. In total, the 100-video sample received 17,375,818 views, 1,285,610 likes, 89,883 favorites, and 100,634 comments. Only 3 of the 25 content characteristics were present in a majority (> 50) of the videos. These were mentions location (below 60th street of Manhattan) (N = 65), mentions cost (N = 61), and mentions cons of pricing (N = 56). Mentioning location had a significant effect on the views (p = 0.0163) and likes (p = 0.0225) a video received. Mentioning cost had a statistical impact on the views (p = 0.0098), likes (p = 0.0128), favorites (p = 0.0128), and comments (p = 0.0030) that the video received. Mentioning the MTA and benefits of the congestion plan significantly lowered metrics of engagement. Themes that emerged were personal, often negative and tended to focus more on cost to citizens and location, despite the evidence of negative public health impacts. This research can be used as a springboard for future research that examines social listening at the intersection of public health and policy.
社会倾听能够更深入地洞察公众对政策提案的看法,纽约市的拥堵收费倡议便是例证。本研究旨在评估TikTok上与纽约市拥堵收费相关的视频样本内容。从TikTok上的#nyccongestionpricing标签中总共提取了100个独特视频,并根据四个不同的重点领域对以下信息的呈现进行编码:视频指标、定价计划细节、定价计划的影响以及用户相关问题。这100个视频样本总共获得了17375818次观看、1285610次点赞、89883次收藏和100634条评论。在25个内容特征中,只有3个在大多数(>50%)视频中出现。这些特征分别是提及地点(曼哈顿第60街以下)(N = 65)、提及成本(N = 61)以及提及定价的弊端(N = 56)。提及地点对视频获得的观看量(p = 0.0163)和点赞量(p = 0.0225)有显著影响。提及成本对视频获得的观看量(p = 0.0098)、点赞量(p = 0.0128)、收藏量(p = 0.0128)和评论量(p = 0.0030)有统计学影响。提及大都会交通管理局(MTA)和拥堵计划的好处会显著降低参与度指标。出现的主题多为个人化的,且往往是负面的,尽管有证据表明对公众健康有负面影响,但这些主题更多地集中在对市民的成本和地点上。这项研究可作为未来研究的跳板,用于考察公共卫生与政策交叉领域的社会倾听。