Bosak Janine, Kulich Clara, Paustian-Underdahl Samantha C, Dingli Rachelle Borg
Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland.
University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2025 Apr;64(2):e12812. doi: 10.1111/bjso.12812. Epub 2024 Oct 28.
Contrary to expectations about solidarity and sisterhood between women, women managers sometimes distance themselves from junior women in the workplace when facing identity threat, that is, the feeling that one's social identity-such as race or gender-is devalued or undermined. For example, women managers might distance themselves from lower status junior women by seeing themselves as more masculine and career committed than their junior women colleagues. To advance our understanding of how to combat self-group distancing, the present research proposed and tested whether taking the perspective of junior women would attenuate these ingroup-distancing tendencies in women managers. Findings from a field study and an experimental study indicated that women managers reported greater self-distancing from junior women (on masculine trait perceptions) compared to women employees. As predicted, this effect was attenuated for women managers with high levels of perspective-taking (Study 1) and for women who were experimentally led to take the perspective of junior women (Study 2). For ratings of career commitment and support for affirmative actions, we did not replicate the self-ingroup distancing effect reported in the literature. Theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed.
与对女性之间团结和姐妹情谊的期望相反,职场中的女性管理者在面临身份威胁时,有时会与年轻女性保持距离,身份威胁即一个人的社会身份(如种族或性别)被贬低或破坏的感觉。例如,女性管理者可能会将自己视为比年轻女性同事更具男子气概且更专注于事业,从而与地位较低的年轻女性保持距离。为了加深我们对如何对抗自我群体疏离的理解,本研究提出并测试了从年轻女性的角度出发是否会减弱女性管理者的这些群体内疏离倾向。一项实地研究和一项实验研究的结果表明,与女性员工相比,女性管理者报告称与年轻女性的自我疏离感更强(在男性特质认知方面)。正如预测的那样,对于具有高度换位思考能力的女性管理者(研究1)以及通过实验引导从年轻女性角度思考的女性(研究2),这种影响有所减弱。对于职业承诺评级和对平权行动的支持,我们并未重现文献中报道的自我群体内疏离效应。讨论了这些发现的理论和实际意义。