Chipeaux Marion, Kulich Clara, Iacoviello Vincenzo, Lorenzi-Cioldi Fabio
Social Psychology, Section of Psychology, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, University of GenevaGeneva, Switzerland.
Social Psychology, Psychology, Faculty of Behavioural and Social Sciences, University of GroningenGroningen, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2017 Aug 28;8:1451. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01451. eCollection 2017.
Empirical findings suggest that members of socially disadvantaged groups who join a better-valued group through individual achievement tend to express low concern for their disadvantaged ingroup (e.g., denial of collective discrimination, low intent to initiate collective action). In the present research, we investigated whether this tendency occurs solely for individuals who have already engaged in social mobility, or also for individuals who psychologically prepare themselves, that is 'anticipate', social mobility. Moreover, we examined the role of group identification in this process. In two studies, we looked at the case of 'frontier workers', that is people who cross a national border every day to work in another country where the salaries are higher thereby achieving a better socio-economic status than in their home-country. Study 1 ( = 176) examined attitudes of French nationals (both the socially mobile and the non-mobile) and of Swiss nationals toward the non-mobile group. As expected, results showed that the mobile French had more negative attitudes than their non-mobile counterparts, but less negative attitudes than the Swiss. In Study 2 ( = 216), we examined ingroup concern at different stages of the social mobility process by comparing the attitudes of French people who worked in Switzerland (mobile individuals), with those who envisioned (anticipators), or not (non-anticipators), to work in Switzerland. The findings revealed that anticipators' motivation to get personally involved in collective action for their French ingroup was lower than the non-anticipators', but higher than the mobile individuals'. Moreover, we found that the decrease in ingroup concern across the different stages of social mobility was accounted for by a lower identification with the inherited ingroup. These findings corroborate the deleterious impact of social mobility on attitudes toward a low-status ingroup, and show that the decrease in ingroup concern already occurs among individuals who anticipate moving up the hierarchy. The discussion focuses on the role of the discounting of inherited identities in both the anticipation and the achievement of a higher-status identity.
实证研究结果表明,社会弱势群体中那些通过个人成就加入更受重视群体的成员,往往对其处于弱势的内群体表现出低度关注(例如,否认集体歧视,发起集体行动的意愿较低)。在本研究中,我们调查了这种倾向是否仅发生在已经实现社会流动的个体身上,还是也发生在那些在心理上为社会流动做准备(即“预期”)的个体身上。此外,我们考察了群体认同在这一过程中的作用。在两项研究中,我们关注了“边境工人”的情况,即那些每天跨越国界到另一个国家工作的人,在那里他们能获得比在本国更高的社会经济地位。研究1(N = 176)考察了法国国民(包括已实现社会流动的和未实现社会流动的)以及瑞士国民对未实现社会流动群体的态度。正如预期的那样,结果表明,已实现社会流动的法国人比未实现社会流动的法国人态度更消极,但比瑞士人消极程度更低。在研究2(N = 216)中,我们通过比较在瑞士工作的法国人(已实现社会流动的个体)、那些设想(预期者)或未设想(非预期者)去瑞士工作的法国人的态度,考察了社会流动过程不同阶段的内群体关注情况。研究结果显示,预期者为其法国内群体亲自参与集体行动的动机低于非预期者,但高于已实现社会流动的个体。此外,我们发现,在社会流动的不同阶段,内群体关注的减少是由于对继承而来的内群体的认同感降低所致。这些研究结果证实了社会流动对低地位内群体态度的有害影响,并表明内群体关注的减少在预期提升社会等级的个体中就已经出现。讨论聚焦于在预期和获得更高地位身份过程中,对继承身份的贬低所起的作用。