The Open University, Walton Hall, Kents Hill, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, UK.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2024 Oct 30;46(4):34. doi: 10.1007/s40656-024-00630-w.
'Obesity' has, for decades, been a subject of intense scientific and public interest, and remains a key target for postgenomic science. I examine the emergence of determinism in research into 'obesity' in the postgenomic field of metabolomics. I argue that determinism appears in metabolomics research in two ways: firstly, fragmentation and narrow construal of the environment is evident in metabolomics studies on weight loss interventions, resulting in particular features of the environment (notably, dietary intake) having outsized influence while the wider social environment is neglected. Secondly, studies aiming to characterize the metabolic signature of 'obesity' are guided by a commitment to a deterministic connection between 'obesity' and dysfunction, leading to a neglect or distortion of metabolic heterogeneity across individuals regardless of body size.
“肥胖”几十年来一直是科学和公众关注的焦点,也是后基因组科学的主要目标。我考察了在后基因组代谢组学领域中对“肥胖”的研究中决定论的出现。我认为,决定论在代谢组学研究中以两种方式出现:首先,在减肥干预的代谢组学研究中,环境的碎片化和狭隘理解显而易见,导致环境的特定特征(特别是饮食摄入)产生了过大的影响,而更广泛的社会环境则被忽视。其次,旨在描述“肥胖”代谢特征的研究受到“肥胖”与功能障碍之间存在确定性联系的指导,导致无论体型大小,个体之间的代谢异质性被忽视或扭曲。