Sato Yoichiro
Department of Physical Therapy, Faculty of Health Sciences, Hokkaido University of Science, Sapporo, Hokkaido, Japan.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2024 Oct 16;18:1459987. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2024.1459987. eCollection 2024.
Although previous studies have suggested that motor adaptation through motor imagery training of similar tasks can improve retention and generalization of motor learning, the benefits of mental and physical training remain unclear for different task difficulties. Two experiments were conducted in this study. The first experiment aimed to determine whether there were differences in movement time (MT) when drawing circles based on three conditions in accordance with Fitts' law. The results showed significant differences in MT among the three conditions ( < 0.001), with MT becoming long as the width of the circle line (which indicated different difficulty level) narrowed. The second experiment aimed to determine whether the task difficulty influenced immediate generalization and retention at 24 h after mental vs. physical training. Participants in both training groups practiced the task with the medium-sized circle, which indicated medium difficulty. The posttest results revealed that mental training leads to considerable performance improvement than physical training, as demonstrated by a shorter MT regardless of the task difficulty level. Meanwhile, the retention test results showed no difference in generalization between mental and physical training. However, generalization of an easier task was more effectively retained than more difficult tasks. These results suggest that mental training can improve performance during the adaptation phase and that difficulty level can influence the degree of retention.
尽管先前的研究表明,通过对相似任务进行运动想象训练来实现运动适应,可以提高运动学习的保持和泛化能力,但对于不同的任务难度,心理训练和身体训练的效果仍不明确。本研究进行了两项实验。第一个实验旨在根据菲茨定律,确定在三种条件下画圆时运动时间(MT)是否存在差异。结果显示,三种条件下的MT存在显著差异(<0.001),随着圆线宽度变窄(这表明难度不同),MT变长。第二个实验旨在确定任务难度是否会影响心理训练与身体训练后24小时的即时泛化和保持情况。两个训练组的参与者均练习中等难度的画中等大小圆的任务。后测结果显示,无论任务难度水平如何,心理训练后的MT均短于身体训练,这表明心理训练比身体训练能带来更显著的表现提升。同时,保持测试结果显示,心理训练和身体训练在泛化方面没有差异。然而,较简单任务的泛化比更难任务的泛化更有效地得以保持。这些结果表明,心理训练可以在适应阶段提高表现,且难度水平会影响保持程度。