Lancet. 2024 Nov 16;404(10466):1955-1988. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(24)01925-1. Epub 2024 Nov 4.
Stillbirth is a devastating and often avoidable adverse pregnancy outcome. Monitoring stillbirth levels and trends-in a comprehensive manner that leaves no one uncounted-is imperative for continuing progress in pregnancy loss reduction. This analysis, completed as part of the Global Burden of Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors Study (GBD) 2021, methodically accounted for different stillbirth definitions with the aim of comprehensively estimating all stillbirths at 20 weeks or longer for 204 countries and territories from 1990 to 2021.
We extracted data on stillbirths from 11 412 sources across 185 of 204 countries and territories, including 234 surveys, 231 published studies, 1633 vital statistics reports, and 10 585 unique location-year combinations from vital registration systems. Our final dataset comprised 11 different definitions, which were adjusted to match two gestational age thresholds: 20 weeks or longer (reference) and 28 weeks or longer (for comparisons). We modelled the ratio of stillbirth rate to neonatal mortality rate with spatiotemporal Gaussian process regression for each location and year, and then used final GBD 2021 assessments of fertility and all-cause neonatal mortality to calculate total stillbirths. Secondary analyses evaluated the number of stillbirths missed with the more restrictive gestational age definition, trends in stillbirths as a function of Socio-demographic Index, and progress in reducing stillbirths relative to neonatal deaths.
In 2021, the global stillbirth rate was 23·0 (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 19·7-27·2) per 1000 births (stillbirths plus livebirths) at 20 weeks' gestation or longer, compared to 16·1 (13·9-19·0) per 1000 births at 28 weeks' gestation or longer. The global neonatal mortality rate in 2021 was 17·1 (14·8-19·9) per 1000 livebirths, corresponding to 2·19 million (1·90-2·55) neonatal deaths. The estimated number of stillbirths occurring at 20 weeks' gestation or longer decreased from 5·08 million (95% UI 4·07-6·35) in 1990 to 3·04 million (2·61-3·62) in 2021, corresponding to a 39·8% (31·8-48·0) reduction, which lagged behind a global improvement in neonatal deaths of 45·6% (36·3-53·1) for the same period (down from 4·03 million [3·86-4·22] neonatal deaths in 1990). Stillbirths in south Asia and sub-Saharan Africa comprised 77·4% (2·35 million of 3·04 million) of the global total, an increase from 60·3% (3·07 million of 5·08 million) in 1990. In 2021, 0·926 million (0·792-1·10) stillbirths, corresponding to 30·5% of the global total (3·04 million), occurred between 20 weeks' gestation and 28 weeks' gestation, with substantial variation at the country level.
Despite the gradual global decline in stillbirths between 1990 and 2021, the overall number of stillbirths remains substantially high. Counting all stillbirths is paramount to progress, as nearly a third-close to 1 million in total-are left uncounted at the 28 weeks or longer threshold. Our findings draw attention to the differential progress in reducing stillbirths, with a high burden concentrated in countries with low development status. Scarce data availability and poor data quality constrain our capacity to precisely account for stillbirths in many locations. Addressing inequities in universal maternal health coverage, strengthening the quality of maternal health care, and improving the robustness of data systems are urgently needed to reduce the global burden of stillbirths.
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
死胎是一种毁灭性且常可避免的不良妊娠结局。全面监测死胎水平和趋势——不遗漏任何一个人——对于继续减少妊娠相关损失至关重要。本分析是全球疾病、伤害和危险因素研究(GBD)2021 研究的一部分,采用不同的死胎定义方法,旨在全面估计所有 20 周或以上的死胎,涵盖了 204 个国家和地区 1990 年至 2021 年的数据。
我们从 185 个国家和地区的 11412 个来源中提取了死胎数据,包括 234 项调查、231 项已发表的研究、1633 份人口统计报告和来自人口登记系统的 10585 个独特地点-年份组合。我们的最终数据集包含 11 种不同的定义,这些定义被调整以匹配两个胎龄阈值:20 周或以上(参考)和 28 周或以上(用于比较)。我们使用空间时间高斯过程回归对每个地点和年份的死胎率与新生儿死亡率之比进行建模,然后使用 GBD 2021 对生育率和全因新生儿死亡率的最终评估来计算总死胎数。次要分析评估了更严格的胎龄定义下错过的死胎数量、死胎随社会人口指数的变化趋势以及与新生儿死亡相比减少死胎的进展情况。
2021 年,全球死胎率为每 1000 例活产(包括死产和活产)23.0(95%置信区间[UI] 19.7-27.2),而 28 周胎龄或以上的死胎率为每 1000 例活产 16.1(13.9-19.0)。2021 年全球新生儿死亡率为每 1000 例活产 17.1(14.8-19.9),对应 219 万(190-255)例新生儿死亡,这一数字在 1990 年为每 1000 例活产 4.03 万(3.86-4.22)。2021 年,20 周胎龄或以上的死胎数量从 1990 年的 508 万(95%UI 407-635)降至 304 万(261-362),降幅为 39.8%(31.8-48.0),而同期新生儿死亡率的全球改善幅度为 45.6%(36.3-53.1),有所滞后(1990 年为每 1000 例活产 4.03 万[3.86-4.22]例新生儿死亡)。南亚和撒哈拉以南非洲的死胎占全球总数的 77.4%(235 万例中的 304 万例),高于 1990 年的 60.3%(508 万例中的 307 万例)。2021 年,20 周至 28 周胎龄之间有 0.926 万(0.792-1.10)例死胎,占全球总数的 30.5%(304 万例),在国家层面存在大量差异。
尽管 1990 年至 2021 年期间全球死胎数量逐渐下降,但总体数量仍然很高。全面统计所有死胎对于取得进展至关重要,因为在 28 周或以上的阈值下,将近三分之一——总共近 100 万例——的死胎没有被统计到。我们的发现引起了人们对减少死胎方面的不同进展的关注,高负担主要集中在发展水平较低的国家。数据可用性和数据质量差限制了我们在许多地方准确统计死胎的能力。迫切需要在普及孕产妇保健方面实现公平、加强孕产妇保健质量以及改善数据系统的稳健性,以减少全球死胎负担。
比尔及梅琳达·盖茨基金会。