Information Systems Department, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel.
Department of Mathematics, Ariel University, Ariel, Israel.
Sci Rep. 2024 Nov 14;14(1):28006. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-78406-2.
Affective states are reflected in the facial expressions of all mammals. Facial behaviors linked to pain have attracted most of the attention so far in non-human animals, leading to the development of numerous instruments for evaluating pain through facial expressions for various animal species. Nevertheless, manual facial expression analysis is susceptible to subjectivity and bias, is labor-intensive and often necessitates specialized expertise and training. This challenge has spurred a growing body of research into automated pain recognition, which has been explored for multiple species, including cats. In our previous studies, we have presented and studied artificial intelligence (AI) pipelines for automated pain recognition in cats using 48 facial landmarks grounded in cats' facial musculature, as well as an automated detector of these landmarks. However, so far automated recognition of pain in cats used solely static information obtained from hand-picked single images of good quality. This study takes a significant step forward in fully automated pain detection applications by presenting an end-to-end AI pipeline that requires no manual efforts in the selection of suitable images or their landmark annotation. By working with video rather than still images, this new pipeline approach also optimises the temporal dimension of visual information capture in a way that is not practical to preform manually. The presented pipeline reaches over 70% and 66% accuracy respectively in two different cat pain datasets, outperforming previous automated landmark-based approaches using single frames under similar conditions, indicating that dynamics matter in cat pain recognition. We further define metrics for measuring different dimensions of deficiencies in datasets with animal pain faces, and investigate their impact on the performance of the presented pain recognition AI pipeline.
情感状态反映在所有哺乳动物的面部表情中。到目前为止,与疼痛相关的面部行为引起了非人类动物的大部分关注,这导致了许多用于通过各种动物物种的面部表情评估疼痛的仪器的发展。然而,手动面部表情分析容易受到主观性和偏见的影响,劳动强度大,并且通常需要专门的专业知识和培训。这一挑战促使人们对自动化疼痛识别进行了越来越多的研究,已经探索了多种物种的自动化疼痛识别,包括猫。在我们之前的研究中,我们提出并研究了使用基于猫面部肌肉的 48 个面部标志的人工智能 (AI) 流水线,以及这些标志的自动探测器,用于自动识别猫的疼痛。然而,到目前为止,仅使用从高质量的手工挑选的单个图像中获取的静态信息来识别猫的疼痛。本研究通过提出一个无需在选择合适的图像或其地标注释方面进行手动操作的端到端 AI 流水线,在全自动疼痛检测应用中迈出了重要的一步。通过使用视频而不是静态图像,这种新的流水线方法还优化了视觉信息采集的时间维度,这在手动操作上是不切实际的。所提出的流水线在两个不同的猫疼痛数据集上分别达到了 70%和 66%的准确率,优于以前在类似条件下使用单帧的基于自动地标识别的方法,这表明动态在猫的疼痛识别中很重要。我们进一步定义了用于测量动物疼痛面部数据集不同维度缺陷的指标,并研究了它们对所提出的疼痛识别 AI 流水线性能的影响。