Bohlman H H, Sachs B L, Carter J R, Riley L, Robinson R A
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1986 Apr;68(4):483-94.
The records of twenty-three patients with a primary benign or malignant osseous neoplasm of the cervical spine were reviewed in an attempt to clarify the most appropriate diagnostic and treatment methods for such tumors. Thirteen patients had a benign tumor and ten patients had a malignant tumor. Nineteen patients had been followed for two to eighteen years (average, six years), and four had died from the malignant disease between one and five months after its discovery. In addition to surgery, medical treatment in the ten patients with a malignant tumor included radiation therapy in seven and chemotherapy in two. Surgical treatment consisted of an anterior and posterior partial resection combined with an arthrodesis in four patients; an anterior partial resection in three, two with an arthrodesis; a posterior partial resection and an arthrodesis in two; and a biopsy but no further treatment in one patient. The duration of survival ranged from one to five months for four patients and from two to three years for four, and was eight and sixteen years in two patients. Two of the thirteen patients with a benign tumor received radiation therapy. Surgical treatment included both an anterior and a posterior resection with arthrodesis in four, an anterior resection in three (with arthrodesis in two), a posterior resection in four (with arthrodesis in three), and a biopsy without surgical resection in two. At follow-up, twelve patients were pain-free and had a solid arthrodesis, although one had required a repeat excision posteriorly. One patient with Gorham's disease (diffuse hemangiomatosis) died. During the period of thirty years (1953 to 1983) when these patients were seen, both the diagnostic methods available and the surgical approaches used have changed. Our present opinion is that all primary osseous lesions of the cervical spine should be carefully defined by arteriography, tomography, bone-scanning, computed tomographic scanning, and myelography in order to properly plan the surgical approach. Total excision of suspect malignant lesions is not attempted, but a major intralesional excision should be carried out to decompress neural and vascular structures and to obtain a biopsy specimen, followed by an arthrodesis to stabilize the spine. For both malignant and benign tumors, an anterior resection should be performed if the tumor is located anteriorly, and a posterior approach should be used if the tumor is predominantly in the posterior vertebral elements. Both of these procedures should be combined with an arthrodesis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
回顾了23例颈椎原发性良性或恶性骨肿瘤患者的病历,以明确此类肿瘤最合适的诊断和治疗方法。13例患者患有良性肿瘤,10例患有恶性肿瘤。19例患者随访了2至18年(平均6年),4例在发现恶性疾病后的1至5个月内死于该疾病。除手术外,10例恶性肿瘤患者的医学治疗包括7例接受放射治疗,2例接受化疗。手术治疗包括4例患者行前路和后路部分切除并结合关节融合术;3例行前路部分切除,其中2例结合关节融合术;2例行后路部分切除并关节融合术;1例仅行活检未进一步治疗。4例患者的生存时间为1至5个月,4例为2至3年,2例分别为8年和16年。13例良性肿瘤患者中有2例接受了放射治疗。手术治疗包括4例行前路和后路切除并关节融合术,3例行前路切除(2例结合关节融合术),4例行后路切除(3例结合关节融合术),2例行活检未行手术切除。随访时,12例患者无痛且关节融合牢固,尽管1例患者需要再次行后路切除。1例戈谢病(弥漫性血管瘤病)患者死亡。在观察这些患者的30年期间(1953年至1983年),可用的诊断方法和采用的手术入路都发生了变化。我们目前的观点是,颈椎的所有原发性骨病变都应通过动脉造影、断层扫描、骨扫描、计算机断层扫描和脊髓造影仔细明确,以便正确规划手术入路。不尝试对可疑恶性病变进行全切除,但应进行较大范围的病损内切除以减压神经和血管结构并获取活检标本,随后行关节融合术以稳定脊柱。对于恶性和良性肿瘤,如果肿瘤位于前方应行前路切除,如果肿瘤主要位于椎体后部则应采用后路入路。这两种手术都应结合关节融合术。(摘要截选至400字)