Huang Xuan, Wang Ying, Yang Xixian, Jiang Ruo, Liu Yicheng, Wang Hui
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Shanghai Sixth People's Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Otolaryngology Institute of Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Dec 4;8:e45763. doi: 10.2196/45763.
Smartphone-based technology has been used to enhance the delivery of health care services to the public in numerous countries.
This study aims to investigate the application of patient-centric mobile medical services accessed through smartphones in the top 100 Chinese public hospitals.
Data on 124 tertiary public hospitals, ranked among the top 100 by the China Hospital Science and Technology Evaluation Metrics of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences (2019) and China's Hospital Rankings of the Hospital Management Institute of Fudan University (2019), were collected from the WeChat platform (Tencent Inc), mobile phone apps, and official websites until February 10, 2021.
A total of 124 tertiary public hospitals, all of which were among the top 100 hospitals according to the 2 ranking lists, were selected for this study. Almost all (122/124, 98.39%) of the hospitals offered basic services such as appointment scheduling, registration, and health education. The majority also provided online access to test reports (95/124, 76.61%), consultations (72/124, 58.06%), and prescriptions (61/124, 49.19%). Among the hospitals offering online prescriptions, the majority (54/61, 88.52%) supported home delivery through third-party carriers. Slightly less than half (57/124, 45.97%) used artificial intelligence for medical guidance. Only a small fraction (8/124, 6.45%) managed chronic diseases through online monitoring and supervision by experienced doctors. Approximately half (60/124, 48.39%) of the included hospitals were officially licensed as internet hospitals approved to provide full online services. Hospitals with official internet hospital licenses provided more extensive digital health offerings. A significantly higher proportion of approved hospitals offered online consultations (29.69% vs 88.33%, r=43.741; P<.001), test reports (62.5% vs 91.67%, r=14.703; P<.001), and chronic disease management (1.56% vs 11.67%, r=5.238; P<.05). These officially approved hospitals tended to provide over 6 mobile medical services, mainly in the regions of Shanghai and Guangdong. This geographic distribution aligned with the overall layout of hospitals included in the study.
Patient-centric mobile medical services offered by the top 100 Chinese public hospitals accessed through smartphones primarily focus on online appointment scheduling, registration, health education, and accessing test reports. The most popular features include online consultations, prescriptions, medication delivery, medical guidance, and early-stage chronic disease management. Approved internet hospitals offer a significantly greater variety of patient-centric mobile medical services compared with unapproved ones.
在许多国家,基于智能手机的技术已被用于改善向公众提供的医疗保健服务。
本研究旨在调查中国排名前100的公立医院中通过智能手机访问的以患者为中心的移动医疗服务的应用情况。
收集了124家三级公立医院的数据,这些医院在中国医学科学院《中国医院科技评价指标》(2019年)和复旦大学医院管理研究所《中国医院排行榜》(2019年)中排名前100,数据收集自微信平台(腾讯公司)、手机应用程序和官方网站,截止日期为2021年2月10日。
本研究共选取了124家三级公立医院,这些医院均在上述两个排名榜单的前100名之内。几乎所有医院(122/124,98.39%)都提供预约挂号、挂号和健康教育等基本服务。大多数医院还提供检验报告在线查询(95/124,76.61%)、在线问诊(72/124,58.06%)和在线开方(61/124,49.19%)服务。在提供在线开方服务的医院中,大多数(54/61,88.52%)支持第三方配送药品到家。略少于一半(57/124,45.97%)的医院使用人工智能进行医疗指导。只有一小部分(8/124,6.45%)通过经验丰富的医生进行在线监测和管理慢性病。纳入研究的医院中约一半(60/124,48.39%)被正式批准为互联网医院,可提供全面的在线服务。拥有互联网医院正式牌照的医院提供更广泛的数字健康服务。获批医院提供在线问诊(29.69%对88.33%,r=43.741;P<0.001)、检验报告查询(62.5%对91.67%,r=14.703;P<0.001)和慢性病管理(1.56%对11.67%,r=5.238;P<0.05)的比例显著更高。这些正式获批的医院往往提供超过6种移动医疗服务,主要集中在上海和广东地区。这种地理分布与纳入研究的医院的总体布局一致。
中国排名前100的公立医院通过智能手机提供的以患者为中心的移动医疗服务主要集中在在线预约挂号、挂号、健康教育和检验报告查询。最受欢迎的功能包括在线问诊、开方、送药、医疗指导和早期慢性病管理。与未获批的医院相比,获批的互联网医院提供的以患者为中心的移动医疗服务种类显著更多。