Irwin Louis N
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Texas at El Paso, El Paso, TX, United States.
Front Psychol. 2024 Nov 22;15:1450754. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1450754. eCollection 2024.
The growing view that consciousness is widespread, multimodal, and evolutionarily non-linear in complexity across the animal kingdom has given rise recently to a variety of strategies for representing the heterogeneous nature of animal phenomenology. While based on markers clearly associated with consciousness in humans, most of these strategies are theoretical constructs lacking empirical data and are based on metrics appropriate for humans but difficult to measure in most non-human species. I propose a novel symbolic profile based on readily observable behaviors that logically constitute subjective experience across the entire spectrum of animals that possess a centralized nervous system. Three modes (markers) of behavior displayed by all animals - volition, interaction, and self-direction - are quantified according to the frequency, variety, and dynamism of each mode. The resulting matrix of 3 modes x 3 metrics can be expressed as a bi-directional heatmap, allowing for quick and easy inter-species comparisons. The overall effect is to highlight both similarities and differences in the subjective experience of animals ranging from crustaceans to primates.
意识在动物王国中具有广泛、多模态且在进化上复杂性呈非线性增长的观点,最近催生了各种用以呈现动物现象学异质性本质的策略。尽管这些策略大多基于与人类意识明显相关的标志,但它们大多是缺乏实证数据的理论构想,且基于适用于人类但在大多数非人类物种中难以测量的指标。我提出一种基于易于观察的行为的新颖符号特征,这些行为在逻辑上构成了拥有中枢神经系统的所有动物的主观体验。所有动物表现出的三种行为模式(标志)——意志、互动和自我导向——根据每种模式的频率、多样性和动态性进行量化。由此产生的3种模式×3种指标的矩阵可以表示为双向热图,便于进行快速且轻松的种间比较。总体效果是突出了从甲壳类动物到灵长类动物在主观体验上的异同。