Hu Yang, Denier Nicole, Ding Lei, Tarafdar Monideepa, Konnikov Alla, Hughes Karen D, Hu Shenggang, Knowles Bran, Shi Enze, AAlshehabi L-Ani Jabir, Rets Irina, Kong Linglong, Yu Dengdeng, Dai Hongsheng, Jiang Bei
Department of Sociology, Lancaster University, Lancaster LA1 4YN, United Kingdom.
Department of Sociology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2H4, Canada.
PNAS Nexus. 2024 Nov 20;3(12):pgae526. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae526. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Job advertisements (ads) represent the first point of contact between employers and job seekers. By signaling characteristics expected of an ideal candidate, job ads "gatekeep" the labor force and configure its composition. Meanwhile, labor force composition can also shape the wording of job ads. This study develops a multidimensional inventory of gender and EDI (equality, diversity, inclusion) language in job ads. Applying this inventory, it adopts an instrumental-variable approach to disentangle the reciprocal relationships between gender/EDI language in job ads and labor force gender/racial composition. Drawing on the analysis of 28.6 million job ads in the United Kingdom in combination with labor force statistics between 2018 and 2023, the findings reveal three distinct mechanisms through which the bidirectional interplay between language in job ads and labor force composition (re)produces or disrupts labor force gender/racial segregation. They highlight both the benefits and limitations of intervening in the language used in job ads to help reduce labor force gender/racial segregation.
招聘广告是雇主与求职者之间的首个接触点。通过表明对理想候选人的期望特征,招聘广告对劳动力进行“把关”并塑造其构成。与此同时,劳动力构成也会影响招聘广告的措辞。本研究编制了一份招聘广告中性别及平等、多样性、包容性(EDI)语言的多维清单。运用这份清单,研究采用工具变量法来厘清招聘广告中的性别/EDI语言与劳动力性别/种族构成之间的相互关系。结合2018年至2023年英国2860万条招聘广告的分析以及劳动力统计数据,研究结果揭示了招聘广告中的语言与劳动力构成之间双向相互作用(再)产生或打破劳动力性别/种族隔离的三种不同机制。研究强调了干预招聘广告中使用的语言以帮助减少劳动力性别/种族隔离的益处和局限性。