Murray Matthew F, Dorsaint Talissa, Dougherty Elizabeth N, Wildes Jennifer E, Haedt-Matt Alissa A
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Neuroscience, University of Chicago, 5841 S. Maryland Ave, MC3077, Chicago, IL 60637, USA.
Department of Psychology, Illinois Institute of Technology, 201 Tech Central, 3424 S. State St., Chicago, IL 60616, USA.
Body Image. 2025 Mar;52:101837. doi: 10.1016/j.bodyim.2024.101837. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
This study examined moderating effects of race and ethnic identity on associations between thin and curvy media exposure and body dissatisfaction in a community sample of Black and white women. Participants (n = 200 white, n = 199 Black) completed a pre-exposure measure of ethnic identity and pre-post measure of body satisfaction (where lower scores indicate dissatisfaction) after randomization to thin or curvy body ideal conditions. Black women endorsed higher pre-exposure ethnic identity than white women but did not differ in level of body dissatisfaction. Moderated-moderation analysis indicated no effect of race nor a conditional effect of ethnic identity on race. Only the thin but not curvy condition was related to greater body dissatisfaction from pre-exposure (M = 3.00, SD =.78) to post-exposure (M = 2.96, SD =.79), t(199) = 2.67, p =.008, d = .19. Findings support growing research suggesting differences in body ideal pressures and associated body dissatisfaction may be less pronounced between Black and white women than in previous decades. Findings have implications for sociocultural models of body dissatisfaction across racial groups and the hypothesis that ethnic identity may prime or buffer certain body ideals.
本研究在一个由黑人和白人女性组成的社区样本中,考察了种族和族裔认同对瘦和曲线美的媒体曝光与身体不满之间关联的调节作用。参与者(200名白人,199名黑人)在被随机分配到瘦或曲线美的身体理想条件后,完成了一项族裔认同的曝光前测量以及身体满意度的曝光前和曝光后测量(分数越低表明越不满意)。黑人女性在曝光前的族裔认同高于白人女性,但在身体不满程度上没有差异。调节-调节分析表明,种族没有影响,族裔认同对种族也没有条件效应。只有瘦的条件(而非曲线美的条件)与曝光前(M = 3.00,SD =.78)到曝光后(M = 2.96,SD =.79)更大的身体不满有关,t(199) = 2.67,p =.008,d =.19。研究结果支持了越来越多的研究,表明黑人和白人女性之间身体理想压力及其相关的身体不满差异可能比前几十年不那么明显。研究结果对不同种族群体身体不满的社会文化模型以及族裔认同可能引发或缓冲某些身体理想的假设具有启示意义。