Fradley K, Bennett K M, Ellis R E, Gibson-Miller J, Bentall R P, Levita L
Department of Psychology, Edge Hill University, Lancashire, England.
Department of Psychology, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, England.
J Child Adolesc Trauma. 2024 Jun 5;17(4):1091-1103. doi: 10.1007/s40653-024-00642-5. eCollection 2024 Dec.
There is a concern that adolescent mental well-being and resilience has been adversely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Consequently, the aim of the current investigation was to track adolescents' resilience from the initial months of the pandemic (T1) to approximately two years later (T2) using both qualitative and quantitative methods. Through interviews, thirty-one adolescents narrated their COVID-19 experiences and reflected on their mental well-being across this timespan. Using these accounts, we identified four groups of adolescents exhibiting one of the following trajectories of resilience: (1) Enduring resilience, (2) Reaching resilience, (3) Declining resilience and (4) Enduring non-resilience. Our findings revealed that most adolescents were able to maintain or develop good resilience on prolonged exposure to COVID-19 adversity (trajectories 1 and 2). This finding is contrary to the prevailing notion that the majority of adolescents' mental well-being and hence resilience was adversely impacted by COVID-19 in the short and long term. Further qualitative analysis identified key factors that contributed to maintaining and developing greater levels of resilience during the pandemic: quality of friendships, quality of family relationships and regaining a sense of control. Lastly, we found a lack of congruence between quantitative and qualitative measures of mental well-being and resilience, suggesting that they might tap into different constructs/experiences. Significantly, our findings highlight that the majority of teens showed adaptive resilience during the pandemic and highlight the need for further longitudinal qualitative and quantitative research to assess both adaptive and maladaptive impacts of adversity on the adolescents' mental well-being and resilience.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40653-024-00642-5.
人们担心新冠疫情对青少年的心理健康和心理韧性产生了不利影响。因此,本调查的目的是通过定性和定量方法,追踪青少年从疫情最初几个月(T1)到大约两年后(T2)的心理韧性情况。通过访谈,31名青少年讲述了他们的新冠经历,并反思了这一时间段内的心理健康状况。利用这些叙述,我们确定了四组青少年,他们展现出以下心理韧性轨迹之一:(1)持久心理韧性,(2)达到心理韧性,(3)心理韧性下降,(4)持久缺乏心理韧性。我们的研究结果表明,大多数青少年在长期接触新冠逆境的情况下能够保持或培养良好的心理韧性(轨迹1和2)。这一发现与普遍观点相反,即大多数青少年的心理健康以及心理韧性在短期和长期都受到了新冠疫情的不利影响。进一步的定性分析确定了在疫情期间有助于维持和培养更高水平心理韧性的关键因素:友谊质量、家庭关系质量和重新获得掌控感。最后,我们发现心理健康和心理韧性的定量和定性测量之间缺乏一致性,这表明它们可能涉及不同的结构/经历。重要的是,我们的研究结果凸显出大多数青少年在疫情期间表现出适应性心理韧性,并强调需要进一步开展纵向定性和定量研究,以评估逆境对青少年心理健康和心理韧性的适应性和适应不良影响。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s40653-024-00642-5获取的补充材料。