Odgers-Jewell Kate, Nelson Alison, Brown Renee, Hunter Nicole, Atkins Tiffany, Menzel Kelly
Faculty of Health Sciences and Medicine, Bond University, Gold Coast, Australia.
The Institute for Urban Indigenous Health, Brisbane, Australia.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):1446. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-06432-9.
A culturally responsive health workforce is essential to ensure the delivery of culturally safe health services that meet Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples needs. In partnership with universities, placement providers play an essential role in creating opportunities for immersive experiences that enable students to develop their cultural responsiveness. This study evaluated students' experiences of an innovative student placement model embedded within an urban Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Community-Controlled Health Organisation.
Students completed pre and post placement surveys administered using a web-based interface. The surveys involved five-point Likert and open-ended response items exploring students' perceptions of their knowledge, skills development, awareness and self-development, and overall placement experience. Frequencies were calculated for the variables of interest and compared between pre and post surveys. The sign test for matched pairs was used to calculate differences between pre and post surveys, and a one-sided hypothesis test was utilised to determine if the level of agreement increased from pre to post survey. Qualitative data obtained for seven questions were thematically analysed using Groundwater Method, an Indigenous data analysis technique.
Between January 1, 2017, and June 30, 2019, 938 students from 32 disciplines were placed within the organisation and its Member services. Survey responses were received from 338 participants pre-placement, and 158 participants post-placement. The matched pre-post group contained 81 students. The results indicate significant positive changes in cultural responsiveness, skills development, awareness, and self-development when comparing pre- and post-placement responses. Students' overall satisfaction with the quality of their placement was positively associated with their intention to work in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health contexts in the future. Key pre-placement themes included competence, cultural skills, support and fear, and key post-placement themes included expertise, cultural responsiveness, learning environment and challenges.
Indigenous-led, regionally coordinated placements in urban Indigenous health contexts can support transformative learning and the development of a culturally responsive workforce. Universities should aim to develop reciprocal relationships with Indigenous-led organisations to support students to develop their cultural responsiveness and improve the provision of culturally safe care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples. Future research should explore the longer-term impacts of student placements on cultural responsiveness, attitudes, values, and behaviours, as well as the experiences of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples interfacing with university students on placement in urban settings. NOTE: We will predominantly use the term 'Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples', as opposed to 'Indigenous' or 'First Nations'. When the term 'Indigenous' is used, it largely relates to government policy - except when referring to Indigenisation of curriculum and Indigenous Knowledges - and where 'First Nations' is used, it is in a global context. In addition, we use the term 'Peoples' to signify that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples are not one People or Nation, but a collective of Peoples and Nations.
一支具有文化响应能力的卫生工作队伍对于确保提供符合原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民需求的文化安全卫生服务至关重要。安置机构与大学合作,在创造沉浸式体验机会方面发挥着重要作用,使学生能够培养他们的文化响应能力。本研究评估了嵌入城市原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民社区控制的卫生组织中的创新学生安置模式下学生的体验。
学生完成了使用基于网络界面进行管理的安置前和安置后调查。调查包括五点李克特量表和开放式回答项目,探索学生对其知识、技能发展、意识和自我发展以及整体安置体验的看法。计算了感兴趣变量的频率,并在安置前和安置后调查之间进行比较。使用配对符号检验来计算安置前和安置后调查之间的差异,并使用单侧假设检验来确定从安置前到安置后调查的一致程度是否增加。对七个问题获得的定性数据使用土著数据分析技术“地下水方法”进行了主题分析。
在2017年1月1日至2019年6月30日期间,来自32个学科的938名学生被安置在该组织及其成员服务机构中。安置前收到了338名参与者的调查回复,安置后收到了158名参与者的回复。配对的安置前后组包含81名学生。结果表明,在比较安置前和安置后的回复时,文化响应能力、技能发展、意识和自我发展方面有显著的积极变化。学生对其安置质量的总体满意度与他们未来在原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民卫生环境中工作的意愿呈正相关。安置前的关键主题包括能力、文化技能、支持和恐惧,安置后的关键主题包括专业知识、文化响应能力、学习环境和挑战。
在城市原住民卫生环境中由原住民主导、区域协调的安置可以支持变革性学习和具有文化响应能力的劳动力的发展。大学应致力于与由原住民主导的组织建立互惠关系,以支持学生培养他们的文化响应能力,并改善为原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民提供的文化安全护理。未来的研究应探索学生安置对文化响应能力、态度、价值观和行为的长期影响,以及原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民与在城市环境中实习的大学生互动的经历。注意:我们将主要使用“原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民”一词,而不是“原住民”或“第一民族”。当使用“原住民”一词时,它主要与政府政策相关——除非涉及课程的本土化和原住民知识——而当使用“第一民族”一词时,它是在全球背景下。此外,我们使用“民族”一词来表示原住民和托雷斯海峡岛民不是一个民族或国家,而是多个民族和国家的集合。