Barbey Cassandra, Bonvallot Nathalie, Clerc Frédéric
Department of Pollutant Metrology, French Research and Safety Institute for the Prevention of Occupational Accidents and Diseases (INRS), 54547 Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy, France.
Univ Rennes, Inserm, EHESP, Irset (Institut de recherche en santé, environnement et travail) - UMR_S 1085, F-35000 Rennes, France.
Saf Health Work. 2024 Dec;15(4):382-395. doi: 10.1016/j.shaw.2024.10.004. Epub 2024 Oct 28.
Individuals are constantly exposed to hazardous factors that can affect their health, the hazards encountered in the workplace can lead to the development of occupational diseases. Risk mitigation measures help to reduce the risks, but they are often designed without consideration of interactions between occupational exposures. Therefore, there is a need for research and it resulted in international research plans and programmes. The aim of this scoping review is to provide an overview of the scientific results related to the link between multiple occupational exposures and human health outcomes. Sixty-three articles were reviewed. Research articles were included only if they mentioned: several combined exposures, the direct characterisation of each exposure, and exposure/health outcome associations. Seven activity sectors were identified: 'extraction and energy production and distribution', 'health care', 'banks, public administration and defence', 'chemical production', 'manufacturing industry', 'agriculture and food industry' and 'transport and logistics'. Six multiple exposures scenarios were identified: chemical ( = 35), chemical/physical-biomechanical ( = 22), chemical/psychosocial-organisational ( = 6), physical-biomechanical ( = 9), physical-biomechanical/psychosocial-organisational ( = 13), and psychosocial-organisational ( = 12). The health problems identified concern nervous, mental, respiratory, musculoskeletal, auditory and other systems. Eighty-eight of 97 (91%) multiple exposure/health problem associations were reported to be statistically significant. Twenty studies (32%) provided specific risk prevention advice for multiple exposures. Prevention aimed at reducing risks to workers' health is still underdeveloped, further research is needed to improve prevention methods. No study was related to biological risk, and some other multiple exposures known to have health effects were not identified as well. This highlights the need for more multiple exposures research.
人们不断接触可能影响其健康的危险因素,工作场所遇到的危险可能导致职业病的发生。风险缓解措施有助于降低风险,但这些措施的设计往往没有考虑职业暴露之间的相互作用。因此,需要进行研究,并由此产生了国际研究计划和项目。本范围综述的目的是概述与多种职业暴露和人类健康结果之间的联系相关的科学成果。共审查了63篇文章。仅当研究文章提及以下内容时才予以纳入:几种综合暴露、每种暴露的直接特征描述以及暴露/健康结果关联。确定了七个活动部门:“采掘与能源生产及分配”、“医疗保健”、“银行、公共行政与国防”、“化学生产”、“制造业”、“农业与食品工业”以及“运输与物流”。确定了六种多重暴露情形:化学(n = 35)、化学/物理 - 生物力学(n = 22)、化学/心理社会 - 组织(n = 6)、物理 - 生物力学(n = 9)、物理 - 生物力学/心理社会 - 组织(n = 13)以及心理社会 - 组织(n = 12)。所确定的健康问题涉及神经、精神、呼吸、肌肉骨骼、听觉和其他系统。97个多重暴露/健康问题关联中有88个(91%)据报告具有统计学意义。20项研究(32%)针对多重暴露提供了具体的风险预防建议。旨在降低对工人健康风险的预防措施仍不完善,需要进一步研究以改进预防方法。没有研究涉及生物风险,一些已知对健康有影响的其他多重暴露也未被识别出来。这凸显了开展更多多重暴露研究的必要性。