Zhou Meng, Li Xuelei, Huang Ting, Wang Mingli, Giorgio Antonio
Department of Ultrasound, Hefei Women and Children's Healthcare Hospital, Hefei, China.
Liver Unit and Interventional Ultrasound Unit, Athena Clinical Institute, Piedimonte Matese (CE), Caserta, Italy.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2024 Dec 5;14(12):9361-9373. doi: 10.21037/qims-24-1379. Epub 2024 Nov 20.
Fetal intracranial volume (ICV) can help evaluate the development of the prenatal central nervous system (CNS) from the three-dimensional (3D) attributes of the cranial structure. Accurate and rapid segmentation and calculation of the ICV are clinically significant. Virtual organ computer-aided analysis (VOCAL) is a commonly used method for measuring fetal ICV. However, its operation is highly complex and time-consuming. This study aimed to optimize the fetal Smart ICV method at 16-19 gestational weeks, verify the consistency of automatic and manual measurement of ICV, and assess an automatic and efficient method for evaluating fetal ICV growth in the second and third trimester of pregnancy.
The ultrasound data of 950 healthy fetuses at 16-34 weeks of gestation were collected. First, the Smart ICV algorithm was optimized at 16-19 weeks. Second, the optimized Smart ICV was compared with the manual VOCAL method. Finally, growth curve and Z-score estimations for fetuses were established for growth assessment via optimized Smart ICV.
Compared with the nonoptimized version, the optimized Smart ICV yielded a lower Hausdorff distance (1.15±0.25 1.31±0.93 mm, P<0.05). Both intra- and inter-observer agreements were at a high level for ICV measurement based optimized Smart ICV [intra-observer intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) =0.998, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.996-0.999; inter-observer ICC =0.991, 95% CI: 0.988-0.996] and the 18 plane-VOCAL (intra-observer ICC =0.997, 95% CI: 0.995-0.998; inter-observer ICC =0.981, 95% CI: 0.979-0.991). Additionally, Bland-Altman analysis showed that the ICV data for the above two models had good agreement. Nevertheless, compared with the 18 plane-VOCAL, the optimized Smart ICV consumed less time (3.7±0.7 153.1±29.5 s, P<0.05). The best fitting model of gestational week for the Smart ICV was a cubic function, expressed as follows: = -44.2445 + 0.1427 + 0.0052 , where is ICV and is the gestational week. In addition, fetal ICV showed an accelerated growth trend in the second trimester.
The optimized Smart ICV showed excellent accuracy and efficiency in ICV measurements at 16-34 gestational weeks. Our results may help to establish a best-fit growth curve for ICV. Our findings suggest that the optimized Smart ICV method has the potential to be a reliable tool for fetal growth assessment during the second and third trimesters.
胎儿颅内体积(ICV)可从颅骨结构的三维(3D)属性帮助评估产前中枢神经系统(CNS)的发育。准确、快速地分割和计算ICV具有临床意义。虚拟器官计算机辅助分析(VOCAL)是测量胎儿ICV的常用方法。然而,其操作高度复杂且耗时。本研究旨在优化孕16 - 19周时的胎儿智能ICV方法,验证ICV自动测量与手动测量的一致性,并评估一种自动、高效的方法来评估妊娠中晚期胎儿ICV的生长情况。
收集950例孕16 - 34周健康胎儿的超声数据。首先,在孕16 - 19周优化智能ICV算法。其次,将优化后的智能ICV与手动VOCAL方法进行比较。最后,通过优化后的智能ICV建立胎儿生长曲线和Z评分估计值以进行生长评估。
与未优化版本相比,优化后的智能ICV豪斯多夫距离更低(1.15±0.25对1.31±0.93mm,P<0.05)。基于优化后的智能ICV进行ICV测量时,观察者内和观察者间的一致性均处于较高水平[观察者内组内相关系数(ICC)=0.998,95%置信区间(CI):0.996 - 0.999;观察者间ICC =0.991,95%CI:0.988 - 0.996],18平面 - VOCAL也是如此(观察者内ICC =0.997,95%CI:0.995 - 0.998;观察者间ICC =0.981,95%CI:0.979 - 0.991)。此外,Bland - Altman分析表明上述两种模型的ICV数据具有良好的一致性。然而,与18平面 - VOCAL相比,优化后的智能ICV耗时更少(3.7±0.7对153.1±29.5秒,P<0.05)。智能ICV孕周的最佳拟合模型为三次函数,表达式如下: = -44.2445 + 0.1427 + 0.0052 ,其中 为ICV, 为孕周。此外,胎儿ICV在孕中期呈加速生长趋势。
优化后的智能ICV在孕16 - 34周的ICV测量中显示出优异的准确性和效率。我们的结果可能有助于建立ICV的最佳拟合生长曲线。我们的研究结果表明,优化后的智能ICV方法有可能成为妊娠中晚期胎儿生长评估的可靠工具。