Paridans Marine, Monseur Justine, Gillain Nicolas, Husson Eddy, Darcis Gilles, Saegerman Claude, Gillet Laurent, Bureau Fabrice, Donneau Anne-Françoise, Guillaume Michèle, Pétré Benoit
Research Unit Public Health: From Biostatistics to Health Promotion, University of Liège, Liège, Belgium.
Infectious Diseases Department, Liège University Hospital, Liège, Belgium.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Dec 19;4(12):e0004066. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0004066. eCollection 2024.
Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccine hesitancy was one of the main global public health threats. Unfortunately, the COVID-19 crisis and its associated risks only reinforced this hesitancy. This study aimed to identify to what extent the COVID-19 vaccination affected confusion around vaccination in general, its change and any associated factors. A questionnaire was distributed to the university population of Liège between April-June 2021 (Time 1) and July-September 2022 (Time 2). The impact of the COVID-19 vaccination on confusion around vaccination in general (score 0 to 100) was divided into three groups based on the tertiles of the study sample at different times and whether or not any change had been observed. Ordinal and multinomial regression analyses were performed to assess the relationship between the confusion and various determinants. The sample consisted of 491 participants. Time 1 vs Time 2, 41.3% vs 35.4% seemed to be less confused, 24.2% vs 28.7% were moderately confused and 34.4% vs 35.8% more confused, respectively. In terms of change, 19.4% of participants were less confused, 55.2% had not changed their opinion and 25.5% were more confused. The determinants causing confusion at both times and regarding change were self-perception, health literacy, past vaccination experiences and COVID-19 related factors (COVID-19 vaccination intention and trust in source of information at Time 1; preferred source of information, trust in vaccine producers and conspiratorial beliefs at Time 2; trust in vaccine producers for change). The results demonstrated that the COVID-19 vaccination impacted confusion around vaccination in general. Both unrelated and related COVID-19 factors, particularly regarding the progression of the pandemic, seem to have contributed to this confusion. Contributing factors require a personalised approach, evidence-based information being communicated with messages adapted to the situation and its evolution designed to allay individuals' fears about vaccination.
甚至在新冠疫情之前,疫苗犹豫就是全球主要的公共卫生威胁之一。不幸的是,新冠危机及其相关风险只是加剧了这种犹豫。本研究旨在确定新冠疫苗接种在多大程度上影响了人们对疫苗接种总体上的困惑、这种困惑的变化以及任何相关因素。2021年4月至6月(时间1)以及2022年7月至9月(时间2)期间,向列日大学的学生群体发放了一份问卷。根据不同时间研究样本的三分位数以及是否观察到任何变化,将新冠疫苗接种对疫苗接种总体困惑(分数0至100)的影响分为三组。进行了有序和多项回归分析,以评估困惑与各种决定因素之间的关系。样本包括491名参与者。时间1与时间2相比,似乎困惑程度降低的比例分别为41.3%和35.4%,中度困惑的比例分别为24.2%和28.7%,困惑程度增加的比例分别为34.4%和35.8%。就变化而言,19.4%的参与者困惑程度降低,55.2%的参与者观点未变,25.5%的参与者困惑程度增加。在两个时间点导致困惑以及与变化相关的决定因素包括自我认知、健康素养、过去的疫苗接种经历以及与新冠相关的因素(时间1的新冠疫苗接种意愿和对信息来源的信任;时间2的首选信息来源、对疫苗生产商的信任和阴谋论信念;变化方面对疫苗生产商的信任)。结果表明,新冠疫苗接种影响了人们对疫苗接种总体上的困惑。与新冠无关和相关的因素,特别是关于疫情的发展,似乎都导致了这种困惑。促成因素需要采取个性化方法,以循证信息结合适应形势及其演变的信息进行传达,旨在减轻个人对疫苗接种的恐惧。