Pratt Jedd, McStravick James, Kennerley Aneurin J, Sale Craig
Department of Sport and Exercise Sciences, Manchester Metropolitan University Institute of Sport, Manchester, UK.
Department of Allied Health Professions and Sport and Exercise Science, School of Human and Health Sciences, University of Huddersfield, Huddersfield, UK.
Exp Physiol. 2025 Mar;110(3):464-477. doi: 10.1113/EP092252. Epub 2024 Dec 20.
Using proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (H MRS) to determine total creatine (tCr) concentrations will become increasingly prevalent, as the role of creatine (Cr) in supporting brain health gains interest. Methodological limitations and margins of error in repeated H MRS, which often surpass reported effects of supplementation, permeate existing literature. We examined the intra- and inter-session reliability and repeatability of H MRS for determining tCr concentrations across multiple brain regions (midbrain, visual cortex and frontal cortex). Eighteen healthy adults aged 20-32 years were recruited (50% female; n = 14 intra-session; n = 15 inter-session). H Magnetic resonance imaging and spectroscopy were completed at 3 T. Intra-session analyses involved repeated H MRS of the midbrain, visual cortex and frontal cortex without participant or voxel repositioning, whereas inter-session analyses involved measurements of the same regions, but with participant and voxel repositioning between repeated measurements. The H MRS data (174 spectra) were analysed using TARQUIN and OSPREY, and voxel fractions (grey/white matter and CSF) were determined using segmentation. Our findings show that tCr concentrations can be determined reliably and repeatably using H MRS, within an error of <2%, and that large inter-regional differences in tCr concentration are present in the human brain. We provide new minimum detectable change data for tCr concentrations, a detailed discussion of the inherent error sources in repeated H MRS, including the substantial effect of the analysis package on tCr quantification, and suggestions for how these should be managed to improve the interpretability and clinical value of future research. More studies are needed to determine whether our findings can be replicated in other centres and different populations.
随着肌酸(Cr)在支持大脑健康方面的作用引发关注,使用质子磁共振波谱(H MRS)来测定总肌酸(tCr)浓度将变得越来越普遍。重复进行H MRS时的方法学局限性和误差范围常常超过所报道的补充剂效果,这在现有文献中随处可见。我们研究了H MRS在多个脑区(中脑、视觉皮层和额叶皮层)测定tCr浓度的组内和组间可靠性及可重复性。招募了18名年龄在20 - 32岁的健康成年人(50%为女性;组内n = 14;组间n = 15)。在3T条件下完成H磁共振成像和波谱分析。组内分析包括在不重新定位参与者或体素的情况下,对中脑、视觉皮层和额叶皮层重复进行H MRS,而组间分析涉及对相同区域的测量,但在重复测量之间重新定位参与者和体素。使用TARQUIN和OSPREY分析H MRS数据(174个波谱),并通过分割确定体素分数(灰质/白质和脑脊液)。我们的研究结果表明,使用H MRS能够可靠且可重复地测定tCr浓度,误差小于2%,并且人脑内tCr浓度存在较大的区域间差异。我们提供了tCr浓度新的最小可检测变化数据,详细讨论了重复进行H MRS时固有的误差来源,包括分析软件包对tCr定量的重大影响,以及关于如何处理这些误差以提高未来研究的可解释性和临床价值的建议。需要更多研究来确定我们的研究结果是否能在其他中心和不同人群中得到重复。