Liu Zhiyuan, Chuang Tzu-Ying, Wang Shan
Division of Natural and Applied Sciences, Duke Kunshan University, Kunshan, China.
Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT, USA.
Pain Rep. 2024 Dec 26;10(1):e1231. doi: 10.1097/PR9.0000000000001231. eCollection 2025 Feb.
Pain-related decision-making can be influenced by the caregiver and sufferer's demographic factors, such as race and gender, which are commonly considered individually. However, such factors may influence pain assessment interdependently based on caregivers' stereotypical beliefs.
This study investigated how sufferers' race and gender affect Chinese observers' evaluations of pain intensity and medication needs and the associations with the observers' race and gender-related stereotypical beliefs.
One hundred sixty-two Chinese participants completed a pain facial expression rating task assessing the level of pain intensity and the extent to which they believe the sufferer needs pain medication for East Asian, White, and Black sufferers, followed by a battery of questionnaires measuring their gender and race role expectation of pain.
Chinese observers were more stringent on East Asians' pain intensity and needs for medication than Whites and Blacks'. However, when Black and East Asian sufferers were perceived to have a similar level of pain, East Asians were more likely to receive medication than Blacks, which is partly due to the observers' stereotypical beliefs that Blacks would have a speedier recovery than East Asians.
Our results provided evidence that in addition to the in-versus-out-group preferences, one's sociocultural-related stereotypical beliefs can account for racial disparities in pain-related decision-making.
与疼痛相关的决策可能会受到照顾者和患者的人口统计学因素影响,比如种族和性别,这些因素通常被单独考虑。然而,基于照顾者的刻板印象,这些因素可能会相互影响疼痛评估。
本研究调查了患者的种族和性别如何影响中国观察者对疼痛强度和药物需求的评估,以及与观察者的种族和性别相关刻板印象信念的关联。
162名中国参与者完成了一项疼痛面部表情评分任务,该任务评估东亚、白种人和黑人患者的疼痛强度水平以及他们认为患者需要止痛药的程度,随后进行一系列问卷,测量他们对疼痛的性别和种族角色期望。
中国观察者对东亚患者的疼痛强度和药物需求比白种人和黑人患者更为严格。然而,当黑人患者和东亚患者被认为疼痛程度相似时,东亚患者比黑人患者更有可能接受药物治疗,这部分是由于观察者的刻板印象,即认为黑人比东亚人恢复得更快。
我们的研究结果表明,除了内群体与外群体偏好之外,一个人的社会文化相关刻板印象信念可以解释与疼痛相关决策中的种族差异。