Kachoria Aparna G, Fatima Hiba, Lightfoot Alexandra F, Tawfik Linda, Healy Joan, Carter Asia, Farahi Narges, Teal E Nicole, Haidar Joumana K, Peterson Herbert B, Menard M Kathryn
Department of Maternal and Child Health, University of North Carolina Gillings School of Global Public Health, Chapel Hill, NC, 27599, USA.
Department of Health Behavior, University of North Carolina Gillings School of Global Public Health, Chapel Hill, NC, 27599, USA.
Implement Sci Commun. 2025 Jan 9;6(1):7. doi: 10.1186/s43058-024-00685-7.
Pregnancy related hypertension is a leading cause of preventable maternal morbidity and mortality in the US, with consistently higher rates affecting racial minorities. Many complications are preventable with timely treatment, in alignment with the Alliance for Innovation on Maternal Health's Patient Safety Bundle ("Bundle"). The Bundle has been implemented successfully in inpatient settings, but 30% of preeclampsia-related morbidity occurs in outpatient settings in North Carolina. To address this, we have integrated community engagement and implementation science approaches to identify facilitators and barriers to Bundle implementation, which supports its adaptation for outpatient settings and identifies implementation strategies to be tested in a subsequent study.
Eleven key informant interviews were conducted across three clinics to assess the implementation needs for effectively utilizing the Bundle. The interview guide was created using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research domains to identify facilitators and barriers to implementation. Additionally, three focus group discussions with patient participants were conducted to understand lived experiences and perceptions of respectful care. A coalition of community partners, patients, providers, those with lived experience, and the research team reviewed materials from the formative study design to dissemination and planning for future study.
Barriers included inadequate provider-patient interaction time, patients' lack of transportation to access care, limited protocols to inform/assess/treat/escalate patients, and workforce capacity (staff training and turnover). Facilitators included staff recognition of the importance of treating preeclampsia, champion buy-in of the Bundle's ability to improve outcomes, co-location of pharmacies for immediate treatment, and staff capacity. Respectful care principles were repeatedly identified as a facilitator for Bundle implementation, specifically for patient awareness of preeclampsia complications and treatment adherence.
Findings highlight the importance of community-engaged approaches. Further, clinic staff regarded Bundle implementation as crucial for the outpatient setting. Identified barriers suggest that strategies should address systemic social supports (i.e., transportation, childcare) and improve access to and use of home blood pressure monitoring. Identified facilitators support improving communication, increasing clinic champion engagement, enabling systems for identifying at-risk patients, and training staff on accurate blood pressure measurement. Successful Bundle implementation requires addressing systemic barriers to delivering respectful care, such as limited time with patients.
在美国,妊娠相关高血压是可预防的孕产妇发病和死亡的主要原因,少数族裔受影响的比率一直较高。通过及时治疗,许多并发症是可以预防的,这与孕产妇健康创新联盟的患者安全包(“安全包”)一致。该安全包已在住院环境中成功实施,但在北卡罗来纳州,30%的子痫前期相关发病发生在门诊环境中。为了解决这个问题,我们整合了社区参与和实施科学方法,以确定安全包实施的促进因素和障碍,这有助于其适用于门诊环境,并确定在后续研究中要测试的实施策略。
在三个诊所进行了11次关键信息人访谈,以评估有效利用安全包的实施需求。访谈指南是使用实施研究综合框架领域创建的,以确定实施的促进因素和障碍。此外,与患者参与者进行了三次焦点小组讨论,以了解他们的生活经历和对尊重护理的看法。一个由社区合作伙伴、患者、提供者、有生活经验者和研究团队组成的联盟审查了从形成性研究设计到传播以及未来研究规划的材料。
障碍包括医患互动时间不足、患者缺乏就医交通、告知/评估/治疗/转诊患者的协议有限以及劳动力能力(员工培训和人员流动)。促进因素包括工作人员认识到治疗子痫前期的重要性、倡导者认可安全包改善结局的能力、药房集中以便立即治疗以及工作人员能力。尊重护理原则多次被确定为安全包实施的促进因素,特别是对于患者对子痫前期并发症的认识和治疗依从性。
研究结果突出了社区参与方法的重要性。此外,诊所工作人员认为安全包的实施对门诊环境至关重要。确定的障碍表明,策略应解决系统性社会支持(即交通、儿童保育)问题,并改善家庭血压监测的获取和使用。确定的促进因素支持改善沟通、增加诊所倡导者的参与度、建立识别高危患者的系统以及培训工作人员准确测量血压。成功实施安全包需要解决提供尊重护理的系统性障碍,如与患者相处时间有限。