Jachymczyk Urszula, Knap Paweł, Lalik Krzysztof
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Robotics, AGH University of Krakow, 30-059, Krakow, Poland.
Sensors (Basel). 2024 Dec 29;25(1):137. doi: 10.3390/s25010137.
In this study, a predictive maintenance (PdM) system focused on feature selection for the detection and classification of simulated defects in wind turbine blades has been developed. Traditional PdM systems often rely on numerous, broadly chosen diagnostic indicators derived from vibration data, yet many of these features offer little added value and may even degrade model performance. General feature selection methods might not be suitable for PdM solutions, as information regarding observed faults is often misinterpreted or lost. To address these issues, a structured feature selection method based on correlation analysis supplemented with comprehensive visual evaluation was proposed. Unlike generic dimensionality reduction techniques, this approach preserves critical domain-specific information and avoids misinterpretation of fault indicators. By applying the proposed method, it was possible to successfully filter out redundant features, enabling simpler machine learning (ML) models to match or even surpass the performance of more complex deep learning (DL) architectures. The best results were achieved by a deep neural network trained on the full dataset, with accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score of 97.30%, 97.23%, 97.23%, and 97.23%, respectively, while the top-performing ML model (a voting classifier trained on the reduced dataset) attained scores of 97.13%, 96.99%, 96.95%, and 96.94%. The proposed method for reducing condition indicators successfully decreased their number by approximately 3.27 times, simultaneously significantly reducing computational time of prediction, reaching up to 50% reduction for complex models. In doing so, we lowered computational demands and improved classification efficiency without compromising accuracy for ML models. Although feature reduction did not similarly benefit the metrics for DL models, these findings highlight that well-chosen, domain-relevant condition indicators can streamline data input and deliver interpretable, cost-effective PdM solutions suitable for industrial applications.
在本研究中,已开发出一种预测性维护(PdM)系统,该系统专注于风力涡轮机叶片模拟缺陷检测与分类的特征选择。传统的PdM系统通常依赖于从振动数据中广泛选取的大量诊断指标,但其中许多特征几乎没有附加值,甚至可能降低模型性能。一般的特征选择方法可能不适用于PdM解决方案,因为关于观察到的故障的信息常常被误解或丢失。为解决这些问题,提出了一种基于相关性分析并辅以全面视觉评估的结构化特征选择方法。与通用的降维技术不同,这种方法保留了关键的特定领域信息,并避免了对故障指标的误解。通过应用所提出的方法,能够成功滤除冗余特征,使更简单的机器学习(ML)模型能够匹配甚至超越更复杂的深度学习(DL)架构的性能。在完整数据集上训练的深度神经网络取得了最佳结果,准确率、精确率、召回率和F1分数分别为97.30%、97.23%、97.23%和97.23%,而表现最佳的ML模型(在简化数据集上训练的投票分类器)的分数为97.13%、96.99%、96.95%和96.94%。所提出的减少状态指标的方法成功地将其数量减少了约3.27倍,同时显著减少了预测的计算时间,对于复杂模型减少高达50%。这样,我们在不影响ML模型准确性的情况下降低了计算需求并提高了分类效率。尽管特征约简对DL模型的指标没有类似的益处,但这些发现突出表明,精心选择的、与领域相关的状态指标可以简化数据输入,并提供适用于工业应用的可解释、经济高效的PdM解决方案。