Kossmann Hanno, Moess Thorsten, Breunig Peter
Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition, Weihenstephan-Triesdorf University of Applied Sciences, Weidenbach, Germany.
PLoS One. 2025 Jan 22;20(1):e0316480. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0316480. eCollection 2025.
As global demand for meat continues to rise, alternative and sustainable methods of production are being explored. Cultivated meat (CM) is one such alternative that holds potential for sustainable production with less environmental impact. This study develops an approach to evaluate CM production based on agricultural feedstock. The specific objectives are to determine the minimum land area required to produce a certain amount of cell medium-feedstock for CM production-on agricultural land and to identify potential future land use scenarios assuming that the macro components of the cell medium are solely produced from common agricultural crops in southern Germany. A linear programming model was developed to analyze four different scenarios of CM production, considering factors such as crop rotation, nutrient sourcing, and solar energy use. The results indicate that CM production using plants as raw material for the cell medium cannot improve land use efficiency substantially compared to conventional pork production. Extraction methods, crop choice, and energy sources will strongly influence future pathways for CM. We also find that there is no substantial benefit from CM in terms of climate change mitigation when feedstock is sourced solely from plants. This study provides valuable insights into the limitations of using agricultural feedstock for sustainable CM production. The findings suggest that future research should focus on optimizing the land use efficiency of CM. This includes exploring alternatives such as sourcing cell media from precision fermentation instead of relying solely on crops, and utilizing upcycling possibilities.
随着全球对肉类的需求持续增长,人们正在探索替代性和可持续的生产方法。细胞培养肉(CM)就是这样一种替代方案,它具有可持续生产且对环境影响较小的潜力。本研究开发了一种基于农业原料评估细胞培养肉生产的方法。具体目标是确定在农业用地上生产一定量用于细胞培养肉生产的细胞培养基原料所需的最小土地面积,并假设细胞培养基的主要成分仅由德国南部常见的农作物生产,确定未来潜在的土地利用情景。开发了一个线性规划模型来分析细胞培养肉生产的四种不同情景,考虑了作物轮作、养分来源和太阳能利用等因素。结果表明,与传统猪肉生产相比,使用植物作为细胞培养基原料的细胞培养肉生产并不能显著提高土地利用效率。提取方法、作物选择和能源将强烈影响细胞培养肉的未来发展路径。我们还发现,当原料仅来自植物时,细胞培养肉在缓解气候变化方面没有实质性益处。本研究为利用农业原料进行可持续细胞培养肉生产的局限性提供了有价值的见解。研究结果表明,未来的研究应专注于优化细胞培养肉的土地利用效率。这包括探索替代方案,如从精准发酵中获取细胞培养基而非仅依赖作物,并利用升级回收的可能性。