Ashraf Saima, Haroon Ammara, Fayyaz Asiya
Saima Ashraf Associate Professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Nishtar Hospital, Multan, Pakistan.
Ammara Haroon Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Nishtar Hospital, Multan, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2025 Jan;41(1):125-129. doi: 10.12669/pjms.41.1.9922.
To compare the efficacy of a probiotic plus antibiotic with antibiotic therapy alone for the prevention of the recurrence of bacterial vaginosis.
A Randomized control trial was conducted in the Gynecological Department of Nishtar Hospital, Multan, between July 2022 and June 2023. One hundred and twenty (N=120) women with bacterial vaginosis, all cured with metronidazole, were enrolled and randomized. In Group-A, Probiotics were administered once a day for 14 days following antibiotic treatment (Tab Metronidazole 400mg, three times a day for seven days). In Group-B, only oral antibiotics were given. The patients were followed up in four visits for five months for bacterial vaginosis recurrence (responders, partial responders, non-responders, and drop-outs) using Amsel criteria by vaginal swabs. All the data was collected on a structured Performa.
The mean age of enrolled 120 women was 32.28±2.58, and 111(92.5%) were married. Of 120 enrolled women, 8 (6.7%) were dropped out. Evaluating the recurrence rate, the probiotic group (n=57) had fewer recurrences than the placebo (n=55) (8.9% vs 21.4%, p-value <0.05). Group-A had a better responder rate at five months of follow-up than the placebo group (39.2% vs. 25.8%) (RR 0.31, 95%CI: 0.1450-0.7998, -Value <0.05). Comparing the effect of probiotics on the components of the Amsel criteria, only vaginal discharge had a statistically significant reduction by using probiotics plus antibiotics (-value≤0.05).
This trial showed that probiotics plus antibiotics significantly reduced bacterial vaginosis recurrences than antibiotics alone.
比较益生菌联合抗生素与单纯抗生素治疗预防细菌性阴道病复发的疗效。
2022年7月至2023年6月在木尔坦尼什塔尔医院妇科进行了一项随机对照试验。招募了120名患有细菌性阴道病且均已用甲硝唑治愈的女性,并将她们随机分组。A组在抗生素治疗后(甲硝唑片400mg,每日三次,共七天)每天服用一次益生菌,持续14天。B组仅给予口服抗生素。通过阴道拭子采用阿姆塞尔标准对患者进行了为期五个月的四次随访,以观察细菌性阴道病复发情况(有反应者、部分反应者、无反应者和退出者)。所有数据均在结构化表格上收集。
纳入的120名女性的平均年龄为32.28±2.58岁,其中111名(92.5%)已婚。在120名纳入研究的女性中,有8名(6.7%)退出。评估复发率,益生菌组(n = 57)的复发次数少于安慰剂组(n = 55)(8.9%对21.4%,p值<0.05)。A组在随访五个月时的反应率优于安慰剂组(39.2%对25.8%)(相对危险度0.31,95%置信区间:0.1450 - 0.7998,p值<0.05)。比较益生菌对阿姆塞尔标准各成分的影响,仅阴道分泌物使用益生菌联合抗生素后有统计学显著减少(p值≤0.05)。
本试验表明,益生菌联合抗生素比单纯抗生素能显著降低细菌性阴道病的复发率。