Mackert Simone, Walker Manuel, Pirlich Nina, Schäuble Jörg C, Cardenas Marban Abimael, Ganter Michael T, Eichenberger Urs, Nübling Matthias, Heidegger Thomas
Department of Anaesthesia, Spital Grabs, 9472, Grabs, Switzerland.
Emergency Department, Hirslanden Klinik St. Anna, Lucerne, Switzerland.
Anaesthesiologie. 2025 Feb;74(2):89-96. doi: 10.1007/s00101-024-01499-x. Epub 2025 Jan 30.
While limited data on the impact of implementing guidelines in airway management on outcomes exist, there is a consensus that the implementation and the adherence to guidelines enhance patient safety. Recently, the Swiss Society for Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine (SSAPM) endorsed the guidelines of The Fondation Latine des Voies Aériennes (FLAVA) as the official guidelines for airway management in Switzerland. This study aimed to determine current practice of airway management in Switzerland.
To determine the available equipment, the differences between institutions and between specialists and residents in dealing with airway management.
In collaboration with the SSAPM, a covering letter with a survey link to the questionnaire used in the online airway management survey among German anesthesiologists was sent to all heads of departments of anesthesia and members of the SSAPM in August 2023. The participants (residents and specialists) were asked about their personal and institutional backgrounds, access to airway management devices, awareness of recognized airway management guidelines and the importance and application of airway management techniques.
Overall, 555 anesthesiologists participated in the survey (response rate 21%). The main findings were: in general, Swiss anesthesia departments are well-equipped and adhere to airway management guidelines. The guidelines of FLAVA are only known by just over 50%. The vast majority used the traditional screening tests to identify an airway that might be potentially difficult to manage. Of the respondents, 25% still adhere to the myth that a mask ventilation check is necessary before the administration of a muscle relaxant and 14% said that their institution used video laryngoscopy as the primary intubation device. More than 80% think that the expertise to perform awake fiberoptic intubation is important for their daily practice; however, 31% consider their expertise in this technique to be insufficient. In other words, there is a big safety gap.
Swiss anesthesia departments are well-equipped and adhere to airway management guidelines. The need for regular training to gain and maintain expertise in managing difficult airways, especially to future specialists, still prevails. Thus, developing and establishing a nationwide educational program in airway management and its continuous evaluation would be a milestone for patient safety.
虽然关于实施气道管理指南对治疗结果影响的数据有限,但人们一致认为,实施和遵守指南可提高患者安全性。最近,瑞士麻醉与围手术期医学协会(SSAPM)认可了拉丁气道基金会(FLAVA)的指南,将其作为瑞士气道管理的官方指南。本研究旨在确定瑞士目前的气道管理实践情况。
确定可用设备、各机构之间以及专家与住院医师在处理气道管理方面的差异。
2023年8月,与SSAPM合作,向所有麻醉科主任和SSAPM成员发送了一封附信,其中包含德国麻醉医师在线气道管理调查中使用的问卷的调查链接。参与者(住院医师和专家)被问及他们的个人和机构背景、气道管理设备的获取情况、对公认气道管理指南的知晓情况以及气道管理技术的重要性和应用情况。
总体而言,555名麻醉医师参与了调查(回复率21%)。主要发现如下:总体而言,瑞士麻醉科设备精良,遵守气道管理指南。只有略多于50%的人知道FLAVA的指南。绝大多数人使用传统筛查测试来识别可能难以管理的气道。在受访者中,25%的人仍然坚信在使用肌肉松弛剂之前有必要进行面罩通气检查,14%的人表示他们所在的机构将视频喉镜作为主要的插管设备。超过80%的人认为进行清醒纤维支气管镜插管的专业技能对他们的日常实践很重要;然而,31%的人认为他们在这项技术方面的专业技能不足。换句话说,存在很大的安全差距。
瑞士麻醉科设备精良,遵守气道管理指南。定期培训以获得和保持处理困难气道的专业技能的需求仍然存在,尤其是对未来的专家而言。因此,制定并建立全国性的气道管理教育计划及其持续评估将是患者安全方面的一个里程碑。